General rating of the project

  • Great

    Votes: 53 72.6%
  • Very Good

    Votes: 16 21.9%
  • Good

    Votes: 4 5.5%
  • So so

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Not Very Good

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Terrible

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    73
Update pics from @CBCScott on twitter

Image17.jpg
Image16.jpg
 

Attachments

  • Image17.jpg
    Image17.jpg
    142.8 KB · Views: 428
  • Image16.jpg
    Image16.jpg
    155.2 KB · Views: 445
:cool: This building is going to be gorgeous when it's done.

The coolest library in the country for sure.

Agreed. How would you rank these:

  • Halifax's new Central Library
  • Toronto Reference Library
  • Vancouver Public Library
  • Library of Parliament (public can only tour, but certainly an incredible library)
  • various university and private libraries (Stauffer at Queen's, TFDD at Calgary, etc)
  • other
 
The coolest library in the country for sure.

I'm looking forward to it! But there is some stiff competition when it comes to Canadian libraries. In Toronto alone I can think of many beautiful/cool libraries:

Vaughan Civic Centre Library:
timthumb.php


Scarborough Civic Centre Library:
1003664889-1003664891.jpg


Lillian H. Smith Library:
doorway_modified.jpg


Runnymede Library:
Runnymede_TPL.jpg


Knox College Library:
Caven-Library01-120dpi1.jpg


Robarts Library:
thomas-fisher-rare-book-library-university-of-toronto.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: AJX
I really like the parliament library, but to me sort of an apples to oranges type comparison. Vancouver's is nice. I don't like Halifax's new library.


Agreed. How would you rank these:

  • Halifax's new Central Library
  • Toronto Reference Library
  • Vancouver Public Library
  • Library of Parliament (public can only tour, but certainly an incredible library)
  • various university and private libraries (Stauffer at Queen's, TFDD at Calgary, etc)
  • other
 
Agreed. How would you rank these:

  • Halifax's new Central Library
  • Toronto Reference Library
  • Vancouver Public Library
  • Library of Parliament (public can only tour, but certainly an incredible library)
  • various university and private libraries (Stauffer at Queen's, TFDD at Calgary, etc)
  • other

Vancouver's library is right up there. Toronto's reference library....great on the inside. Library of Parliament, is a one of a kind.
 
00-2016 Sept 9 image 001.JPG 00-2016 Sept 9 image 007.JPG 00-2016 Sept 9 image 008.JPG 00-2016 Sept 9 image 022.JPG 00-2016 Sept 9 image 024.JPG 00-2016 Sept 9 image 025.JPG 00-2016 Sept 9 image 028.JPG 00-2016 Sept 9 image 029.JPG 802_0000.jpg 803_0000.jpg
 

Attachments

  • 00-2016 Sept 9 image 001.JPG
    00-2016 Sept 9 image 001.JPG
    1.9 MB · Views: 360
  • 00-2016 Sept 9 image 007.JPG
    00-2016 Sept 9 image 007.JPG
    1.6 MB · Views: 392
  • 00-2016 Sept 9 image 008.JPG
    00-2016 Sept 9 image 008.JPG
    1.5 MB · Views: 366
  • 00-2016 Sept 9 image 022.JPG
    00-2016 Sept 9 image 022.JPG
    1.8 MB · Views: 380
  • 00-2016 Sept 9 image 024.JPG
    00-2016 Sept 9 image 024.JPG
    1.3 MB · Views: 375
  • 00-2016 Sept 9 image 025.JPG
    00-2016 Sept 9 image 025.JPG
    967.6 KB · Views: 403
  • 00-2016 Sept 9 image 028.JPG
    00-2016 Sept 9 image 028.JPG
    1.2 MB · Views: 345
  • 00-2016 Sept 9 image 029.JPG
    00-2016 Sept 9 image 029.JPG
    2 MB · Views: 391
  • 802_0000.jpg
    802_0000.jpg
    1.8 MB · Views: 367
  • 803_0000.jpg
    803_0000.jpg
    1.9 MB · Views: 389
Toronto does have some cool libraries. Props to them for building such a strong network.

You know what REALLY sets Calgary's NCL apart though? It is literally intertwined with the city. I mean, a C-train runs through it from one direction, and the sidewalk continues through it the other direction. Few modern designs give nearly as much tribute to context, regardless of building type. Having a transparent, playful, permeable, inspired-by-nature-but-built-with-digital-technology, and central design is really what a public library is all about. ;)

Andrew Carnegie would be proud.
 
Here's hoping they one day renovate City Hall to create a more open pathway that connects 8th ave on either side. 8th Ave has the potential to be a spectacular street connecting the Armoury and Millennium Park in the west to Fort Calgary in the east and going through City Hall and the library (not to mention Art Commons, the Core, etc.).
 
I believe that's the long term plan. At least having an opening through city hall towards the library is. I like the scope of your thinking though. I hadn't considered that Mewata and the New Library become bookends to one long feature road. There would be quite a lot to see on and just off of 8th Ave.

To me the biggest obstacle to your plan isn't city hall though, it's the generally declining quality of the streetscape from 5th street westwards to 11th street. Especially in the blocks areound 9th and 10th streets and 8th ave. Longer term there's room for hope though. 8th & 8th has seen a lot of improvment in the last 10 years and the WV project begins around 11th & 9th. Hopefully there will be interest in bridging the gap.
 
Last edited:
Toronto does have some cool libraries. Props to them for building such a strong network.

You know what REALLY sets Calgary's NCL apart though? It is literally intertwined with the city. I mean, a C-train runs through it from one direction, and the sidewalk continues through it the other direction. Few modern designs give nearly as much tribute to context, regardless of building type. Having a transparent, playful, permeable, inspired-by-nature-but-built-with-digital-technology, and central design is really what a public library is all about. ;)

Andrew Carnegie would be proud.

Snohetta did a great job working with a parcel of land that was difficult to work with. I never thought about the relevance of the C-Train going through one area and a pedestrian way through another, but that's really cool. Calgarians will be proud of this building when it's done.
 
Here's hoping they one day renovate City Hall to create a more open pathway that connects 8th ave on either side. 8th Ave has the potential to be a spectacular street connecting the Armoury and Millennium Park in the west to Fort Calgary in the east and going through City Hall and the library (not to mention Art Commons, the Core, etc.).

Maybe a hail storm will wipe out the new city hall building and we can get a re-build ;).

If they could get 8th ave to run straight through to EV, and then connect nicely to the EV RIFF, that would be great. I have heard that they are looking at opening up a passage through city hall for 8th ave, but not sure where they are at.
 

Back
Top