Go Elevated or try for Underground?

  • Work with the province and go with the Elevated option

    Votes: 66 66.7%
  • Try another approach and go for Underground option

    Votes: 29 29.3%
  • Cancel it altogether

    Votes: 1 1.0%
  • Go with a BRT solution

    Votes: 3 3.0%

  • Total voters
    99
It's here, you can also see the end of the 3rd street platform
Wow, totally didn't see that. Thanks.

Now I can make out the tracks, but the car and lack of catenary wires threw me.

Aerial shot of the area:
Screenshot 2026-02-11 at 11.09.13 AM.png
 
1770751324500.png


"Noise and vibration impacts." - my brother in Christ this is an electrified LRT line that will be quieter than a diesel bus. The only reason the current LRTs in downtown rumble is because they are street running and vibrate into the asphalt roadway. This will be built on a guideway with continuous weld rail and resilient low vibration concrete ties. Not to mention freight trains pass directly adjacent to this station. What are we even doing here??
 
Lol for real

Elevated trains are cool across the planet, Chicago, Paris, Tokyo, Pusan, Vancouver; but they are a concern for one of the worst downtowns of North America. Build the damn thing
 
What are we even doing here??
It seems like they're fishing for overwhelming complaints so that they don't have to do it. Which makes me wonder what work (if any) they've been doing on the DT alignment over the last 13 months and if they have an alternative in mind. Which I think could mean quashing the connection to the north and they want political cover for that decision.

Or maybe they just haven't done any work and this is all they could slap together for the engagement they promised...
 
View attachment 715440

"Noise and vibration impacts." - my brother in Christ this is an electrified LRT line that will be quieter than a diesel bus. The only reason the current LRTs in downtown rumble is because they are street running and vibrate into the asphalt roadway. This will be built on a guideway with continuous weld rail and resilient low vibration concrete ties. Not to mention freight trains pass directly adjacent to this station. What are we even doing here??
Not to mention we currently have elevated trains, and they're not an issue. Only thing that could be an issue in this picture is when you get the turns, if they're not wide enough there is going to be noises from the steel wheels.s
 
Not to mention we currently have elevated trains, and they're not an issue. Only thing that could be an issue in this picture is when you get the turns, if they're not wide enough there is going to be noises from the steel wheels.s

This is something that shouldn't just be dismissed, underground metros screech on turns, outdoor LRT tracks are worse.
Might be good reason to completely cover the track for that curved part. Won't eliminate the noise but it'll reduce it.
 
This is something that shouldn't just be dismissed, underground metros screech on turns, outdoor LRT tracks are worse.
Might be good reason to completely cover the track for that curved part. Won't eliminate the noise but it'll reduce it.
Like the city hall turn under the library. Or just making the turn less sharp.
 
Not much of a surprise but downtown businesses hate the idea of an elevated line but 88% of them will suck it up and live with it if that's the only option available.

Unless we change provincial governments or premiers any time soon, I am fairly certain elevated is going to be the only option available.

 
If we could wave a magic wand, I would put the red and blue line underground and run the green line on the surface. With the situation we're in funding-wise, my crystal ball tells me we'll be doing elevated, as I can't see where the money's going to come from for underground.
There's a chance that some things come together, such as the NDP getting elected, and oil prices picking up, and then we'll see. Maybe it goes back to underground.
 

Back
Top