adma
Superstar
At the Handyman Shop's replacement uses brick to at least attempt to tie it into the streetscape. It maintains the curve in the facade and has some decent details like the bay window. It's a handsome addition that will only be rejected by the "it must new modernist!" crowd to whom a grey wall with some randomly placed windows is deemed something that Victorian arterial infill should absolutely to aspire to be.
But a teardown is a teardown is a teardown, IOW it would also be rejected by the more vociferous streetscape-heritage-at-all-costs crowd. Sort of how the recent Beech-house teardown controversy would have been no different in its fundamentals had the proposed replacement been "traditionalist" in design...