Jaye101
Active Member
There is some truth in this statement. But I think the main difference between Sheppard LRT and the LRT systems in Calgary or Edmonton (and the planned Ottawa LRT) is that LRT lines in all those cities go through the CBD. Even though those systems have on-street sections, they function like a light metro, getting not only walk-in riders but also those transferring from buses or driving to an LRT station. Since they pass through the CBD, decent demand level is guaranteed.
In contrast, Sheppard East LRT is not going to serve any major destinations. Don Mills Stn is just a transfer point for the majority of riders. UofT Scarborough (if the line goes there) and STC (even if the line passed through it) are destinations but they are no match for CBD.
So, TTC and / or Metrolinx might be concerned that Sheppard East LRT is not going to get many riders transferring from buses (and none from park-and-ride) anyway; even if it is designed as a fast trunk line. Probably, that's why they gear the design towards a streetcar line in dedicated lanes, but with rather frequent stop spacing. That way, they can at least save some operating costs by not having to run parallel bus service. I doubt that it is a good idea; but they have their constraints and must address them.
With all door loading there is no reason whatsoever that the LRT should not replace the bus service along the same route. It makes for a more efficient transit model and the increase travel time will be unnoticeable. It will encourage consistent development along the route to support the development of a neighbourhood rather than nodal development at major intersections. It will make a better city.
The only thing we should be worrying about with travel times here is if they're going to give the LRVs full priority at signalized intersections. This will be what will make or break this line, not a couple of stations.
On streets like Spadina and St Clair where more people use transit that drive cars, full signal priority is not given.. I just hope the wind blows in another direction when this train pulls up.