[nfitz]

Are we sure cut and cover wasn't used at all for the Broadway extension?

Also: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/brit...oject-will-close-1-block-for-months-9.6952544

Only for stations. I've been across there many times on the B-Line bus since construction started. I've never seen it closed (and obviously I wasn't there at that time - but normally I'm travelling no further east than Cambie).

The stations are of course cut and cover, and have enough of a temporary roof to let traffic continue.

That's certainly not the busiest section of Broadway; I believe all the concern was about West Broadway, not East Broadway.

They've actually temporarily joined East Broadway and East 9th via Quebec Street, so you can still get to Main Street. You can see the Mount Pleasant station box along the upper edge of the photo. North is down.

 

[nfitz]

I think we'd have to be fair and compare coverage too - a $100b 401 tunnel is going to be a lot longer than the Sheppard subway extension. The $100b cost comes from building a tunnel from Milton to Pickering basically. I think this is unlikely and that the tunnel will likely be proposed at less than half that size, focusing on from the 427 to 404, and that tunnel is estimated to be closer to the $30 billion range.

Any idea how frequent the emergency exits need to be in Ontario for a tunnel like 401?

 

[Westey]

I think we'd have to be fair and compare coverage too - a $100b 401 tunnel is going to be a lot longer than the Sheppard subway extension. The $100b cost comes from building a tunnel from Milton to Pickering basically. I think this is unlikely and that the tunnel will likely be proposed at less than half that size, focusing on from the 427 to 404, and that tunnel is estimated to be closer to the $30 billion range.

I thought MTO looked at this "Big Bold Idea" back in 2019 or so. That is, the tunnel from 427 to 404.
I recall MTO estimate was $50B or so (based on construction costs at the time).

 

[christiesplits]

Lobbyist activity for the Sheppard West extension, via Matt Elliott's City Hall Watcher newsletter:

 

[Northern Light]

Lobbyist activity for the Sheppard West extension, via Matt Elliott's City Hall Watcher newsletter:

View attachment 727255

GS offices are on Wilson, but they manage own/rental on Sheppard just east of Bathurst (among many others).

In downtown, you might know them as 'Great Wise' and a large landlord in St. Jamestown.

 

[Monarch Butterfly]

Any development and/or redevelopment along the Line 4 extensions should be within 15-minute neighbourhoods. A 15-minute neighbourhood is an urban planning concept where residents can access most of their daily needs, such as work, shopping, education, and healthcare, within a 15-minute walk or bike ride from their homes. This approach aims to promote sustainable living, reduce car dependency, and enhance the quality of life in communities.

 

[Rainforest]

I do not enjoy raining on your parade, but - we need some realism.

15-minute neighbourhood is a totally unworkable concept.

People can do grocery shopping and send children to a local school. That largely happens already. With a considerable effort, local availability of primary health care / family doctors can be assured (perhaps). Need to fix the shortage of doctors for that, but at least this is doable in theory.

Everything else requires longer trips in a big city. Most of people will not find a job that needs their particular skill set in the 15-minute neighbourhood. You can't build a hospital or a university in every 15-minute neighbourhood. To reach a surgeon or a kidney expert, to enroll in a post-secondary program that fits your passion, you will need to travel longer. Probably, you will need to cross half of the city. Even for retail shopping, people will find a better choice and/or a better price away from their home, unless you abolish all competition between the retailers and make them all carry the same set of goods for the same price.

The only viable 15-minute neighbourhood, is an isolated 19-th century village. Where everyone works in the field, at the local blacksmith's, or in the local shop (one for the whole village). All kids go to the local school (grade 1-4), noone needs more education. Modern high-tech jobs or advanced medical procedures are unheard of.

 

[nfitz]

15-minute neighbourhood is a totally unworkable concept.

People can do grocery shopping and send children to a local school. That largely happens already. With a considerable effort, local availability of primary health care / family doctors can be assured (perhaps). Need to fix the shortage of doctors for that, but at least this is doable in theory.

Everything else requires longer trips in a big city. Most of people will not find a job that needs their particular skill set in the 15-minute neighbourhood. You can't build a hospital or a university in every 15-minute neighbourhood. To reach a surgeon or a kidney expert, to enroll in a post-secondary program that fits your passion, you will need to travel longer. Probably, you will need to cross half of the city. Even for retail shopping, people will find a better choice and/or a better price away from their home, unless you abolish all competition between the retailers and make them all carry the same set of goods for the same price.

The only viable 15-minute neighbourhood, is an isolated 19-th century village. Where everyone works in the field, at the local blacksmith's, or in the local shop (one for the whole village). All kids go to the local school (grade 1-4), noone needs more education. Modern high-tech jobs or advanced medical procedures are unheard of.

I don't think 15-minute neighbourhood's have anything to do with medical facilities, or even most work places.

Nor is it about finding the cheapest price in town. Personally, I can find most things I regularly need within a 15-minute walk. Even more within a 15-minute streetcar ride.

Can I save a few cents by shopping at Costco. Well yeah, but then it's a 25-minute drive, with no exercise, to sell out my soul to an ironically souless Yankee corporation.

 

[Steve X]

I do not enjoy raining on your parade, but - we need some realism.

15-minute neighbourhood is a totally unworkable concept.

People can do grocery shopping and send children to a local school. That largely happens already. With a considerable effort, local availability of primary health care / family doctors can be assured (perhaps). Need to fix the shortage of doctors for that, but at least this is doable in theory.

Everything else requires longer trips in a big city. Most of people will not find a job that needs their particular skill set in the 15-minute neighbourhood. You can't build a hospital or a university in every 15-minute neighbourhood. To reach a surgeon or a kidney expert, to enroll in a post-secondary program that fits your passion, you will need to travel longer. Probably, you will need to cross half of the city. Even for retail shopping, people will find a better choice and/or a better price away from their home, unless you abolish all competition between the retailers and make them all carry the same set of goods for the same price.

The only viable 15-minute neighbourhood, is an isolated 19-th century village. Where everyone works in the field, at the local blacksmith's, or in the local shop (one for the whole village). All kids go to the local school (grade 1-4), noone needs more education. Modern high-tech jobs or advanced medical procedures are unheard of.

A 15-minute neighbourhood would be for one's basic needs. School, recreation, library, park, groceries and basic minimum wage jobs can all be within the area. For an average person, this would mean the person won't have to leave the neighbourhood for most days of the month. Your doctor visits, MRI scan or highly educated technical jobs would not be located here. It just doesn't make sense.

If they can achieve this, transit would be more appealing while traffic will reduce. However given the number of specialized jobs out there that people do these days, it seems impossible to just stay within 15 min of home. People are commuting over an hour for minimum wage jobs.

 

[CapitalSeven]

Gee, I've lived in a mostly 15 minute neighborhood for decades. I'm shocked to find I imagined it all. I'm waking up in the shower in the burbs!

 

[Rainforest]

Gee, I've lived in a mostly 15 minute neighborhood for decades. I'm shocked to find I imagined it all. I'm waking up in the shower in the burbs!

That means, you can reach you job in 15 min, all your medical appointments (if any) are within 15 min, and you got your post-secondary education living in a 15-min neighbourhood too? Good for you, but how common is that on the social scale?

The original claim is "residents can access most of their daily needs, such as work, shopping, education, and healthcare, within a 15-minute walk or bike ride from their homes".

 

[Rainforest]

A 15-minute neighbourhood would be for one's basic needs. School, recreation, library, park, groceries and basic minimum wage jobs can all be within the area. For an average person, this would mean the person won't have to leave the neighbourhood for most days of the month. Your doctor visits, MRI scan or highly educated technical jobs would not be located here. It just doesn't make sense.

If they can achieve this, transit would be more appealing while traffic will reduce. However given the number of specialized jobs out there that people do these days, it seems impossible to just stay within 15 min of home. People are commuting over an hour for minimum wage jobs.

I don't think 15-minute neighbourhood's have anything to do with medical facilities, or even most work places.

Nor is it about finding the cheapest price in town. Personally, I can find most things I regularly need within a 15-minute walk. Even more within a 15-minute streetcar ride.

Can I save a few cents by shopping at Costco. Well yeah, but then it's a 25-minute drive, with no exercise, to sell out my soul to an ironically souless Yankee corporation.

I think we need to be more clear with definitions here. If we exclude trips to/from the job or the university/college from the 15-min requirement, and exclude trips that most people don't make on the daily basis (a medical specialist, museum, boutique shopping, airport or train station etc), then a 15-min fulfillment of other daily needs is a viable option.

Basically, we are saying "people should not need to drive to get their groceries, or to get their kids to kindergarten / school". Sure, that's a good concept, and a realistic one.

 

[Rainforest]

It is worth noting that most of public transit trips take more than 15 min, if we count the door-to-door time. Most of people will need at least 10 min before and after they use transit: 5+ min to get to the transit stop, and 5+ min to get from the transit stop to where you are going. That means, even if in the most optimal case, a direct subway ride, you only have 5 min for the actual ride. Your destination should be no further than 3-4 km from you origin, if you are to make the trip in 15 min.

If you take surface transit, add at least 5 min waiting for the vehicle. And if a transfer is involved; bus to subway, bus to bus, streetcar to streetcar etc, then very few trips can be completed in less than 25-30 min.

Until recently, I had a job located very conveniently for a transit trip. 6 km by bus, then one stop by subway. The combined time in the moving vehicles only, around 15 min if everything goes smoothly. But the total trip time doors to doors? 35 min on average.

You see a large city with a large, extensively used transit system, that many residents ride to get to their jobs? Almost by definition, this is not a "15-min city" in terms of trips to work.

 

[urbanclient]

I do not enjoy raining on your parade, but - we need some realism.

15-minute neighbourhood is a totally unworkable concept.

People can do grocery shopping and send children to a local school. That largely happens already. With a considerable effort, local availability of primary health care / family doctors can be assured (perhaps). Need to fix the shortage of doctors for that, but at least this is doable in theory.

Everything else requires longer trips in a big city. Most of people will not find a job that needs their particular skill set in the 15-minute neighbourhood. You can't build a hospital or a university in every 15-minute neighbourhood. To reach a surgeon or a kidney expert, to enroll in a post-secondary program that fits your passion, you will need to travel longer. Probably, you will need to cross half of the city. Even for retail shopping, people will find a better choice and/or a better price away from their home, unless you abolish all competition between the retailers and make them all carry the same set of goods for the same price.

The only viable 15-minute neighbourhood, is an isolated 19-th century village. Where everyone works in the field, at the local blacksmith's, or in the local shop (one for the whole village). All kids go to the local school (grade 1-4), noone needs more education. Modern high-tech jobs or advanced medical procedures are unheard of.

I believe @Monarch Butterfly said "can access most of their daily needs".

The other rebuttal is that about 1/3rd of people have a Bachelor's degree or higher in Canada, and only around 2/3rds have post-secondary education. A 15-minute neighbourhood is viable as long as you don't have to travel to a hospital or university campus. People including myself, make the mistake of driving long distances for cheaper goods, but forget to factor in cost of gas, car depreciation, and time. The rise of e-commerce makes 15 minute even more viable. The more high-tech a job is, the more likely it is to be remote. Companies are still hiring fully remote in 2026.

I would include transit into the equation, but I apparently the standard definition is walking and biking only.

 

[Rainforest]

I believe @Monarch Butterfly said "can access most of their daily needs".

I accept that "most" disclamer for non-daily/occasional trips, such as trips to medical specialists (that are non-daily for most people).

However, trips to/from job is a major part of life for many people, and a part of their daily routines. And, should be included in the concept one way or another.

The other rebuttal is that about 1/3rd of people have a Bachelor's degree or higher in Canada, and only around 2/3rds have post-secondary education. A 15-minute neighbourhood is viable as long as you don't have to travel to a hospital or university campus. People including myself, make the mistake of driving long distances for cheaper goods, but forget to factor in cost of gas, car depreciation, and time. The rise of e-commerce makes 15 minute even more viable. The more high-tech a job is, the more likely it is to be remote. Companies are still hiring fully remote in 2026.

E-commerce (home delivery) hides the actual trip from the end user, but in fact it might be very car-dependent. Unless they bank orders from each area and then send one track / van to deliver all of them, it can involve more car kilometres travelled than people visiting retail stores in-person (which can be done by public transit if it exists in the area).

I would include transit into the equation, but I apparently the standard definition is walking and biking only.

I have an issue with that standard definition. If the concept is primarily targeting large cities, where public transit plays and will continue to play a prominent role, then how can it exclude public transit. I believe the concept needs to be modified, and renamed if it is no longer "15-min", but it has to define the role and expectations for public transit.