Col. Flagg sez:
REBEL COLUMN UPDATE: For the first time ever, I've been "fact-checked"! TorStar writer and twitter gadfly Matt Elliott, aka "Graphic Matt", rushed a rebuttal piece to my Monday The Rebel post that exposed a $7.2 billion hike over the next four years under the Tory administration. Matt's rebuttal was spurred on when Rob Ford's office e-mailed my Rebel post out to his entire distribution list on Tuesday afternoon.
Elliott correctly points out that the $11.5 billion 2015 City of Toronto Operating Budget figure I quoted included what has been in the past referred to as the "Rate-Supported Budget" - which, under Ford, was the not-for-profit, revenue-neutral provision of garbage, water, and parking services to the people of Toronto. In the Ford years, neither the city nor the media considered this part of what was referred to in colloquial terms as the Operating Budget.
Starting with John Tory's first budget passed in March 2015, for some reason they have folded this amount in with the rest of the budget, making the budgetary increase appear larger in absolute dollar terms than I reported in the story. Elliott dismisses this confusion as an "election year quirk", but this is not a valid explanation. Election year or not, the two numbers could have been reported separately according to custom, with no compelling reason at all why not. Elliott's explanation does not hold water, and struck me as a smokescreen to hide the truth.
Thinking it through, it appears that Graphic Matt has unwittingly exposed a significant policy change at the City of Toronto under John Tory, that perhaps they were trying to hide. The end result of the way the city has reported the 2015 operating budget is this: going forward, your water usage and your garbage usage are heretofore to be considered CITY GOVERNMENT EXPENSES instead of SERVICES RENDERED AT COST. The implications of this are ugly for the taxpayer: reduced transparency regarding costs and revenues of these services; a higher absolute budget baseline from which to work from for future years' spending increases; and the pretext from which to begin rationing our water and garbage usage in the name of "austerity" and "conservation" when they feel the time is right.
I'm working on this topic as a column for The Rebel. Leave your thoughts and comments on this topic below. In the meantime, here's the link to his TorStar piece that shows how very, very touchy TorStar is to protect the agenda of its crony-corporatist Liberal Uber-Mayor, John Tory.
-Neil