News   GLOBAL  |  Apr 02, 2020
 8.6K     0 
News   GLOBAL  |  Apr 01, 2020
 39K     0 
News   GLOBAL  |  Apr 01, 2020
 4.8K     0 

I wonder how much of this has to do with technology.

Younger people used to work customer service jobs like retail and restaurants. Now those same jobs are replaced with apps, kiosks and self checkouts.

I'm a millenial and even I'm seeing jobs replaced by technology. Not all jobs but enough to make you see an issue.
Canadian companies are too miserly to even do that, nearly everyone at the fast food register, delivering food, or in the kitchen these days is an immigrant or TFW from the Philippines/Indian subcontinent.

Minimum-wage immigration (wage suppression & socialized costs) + cartelization/lack of productivity investment (low innovation) + high COL/regulatory regime (high cost of business & entry) + economic drag from high government debt = low productivity increase.
 
Last edited:
Comparison to other countries from the Economist.

It’s very clear, the Trudeau government has been an unmitigated historic disaster. There is fundamentally no reason why our country needed to be set on this trajectory.

1712667309250.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Building churches and making sausage I presume?

Since you asked, you made me curious................

1712677778022.png

From: https://pie.net.pl/en/polands-gdp-growth-in-2024-to-reach-2-3/

The black line is overall GDP growth, curiously it peaked in the pandemic, and the year after, the rest of the chart is fairly unremarkable. But 2021/2022 saw phenomenal growth.

Whoa......look at the inflation numbers:

1712677992830.png


Source: https://www.economicsobservatory.com/what-next-for-polands-economy

From the above, Polish inflation peaked at ~20% in the last year

This has me curious and I will have to look into this further.
 
Comparison to other countries from the Economist.

It’s very clear, the Trudeau government has been an unmitigated historic disaster. There is fundamentally no reason why our country needed to be set on this trajectory.

View attachment 554882

LOL. The fun of choosing your starting and ending points to manufacture a narrative. Very legacy media of the Economist.

1712678266678.png
 
Last edited:
Real GDP and real GDP per capita are very different things in Canada.
Not for the large majority. What you really need to accurately make claims in these circumstances is the equivalent to "same-store sales" used in retail, which I don't know if it exists out there, though it sounds difficult to obtain. But you can easily have GPD/capita rising for the majority while dragged overall down by new arrivals. That means there isn't the greatest economic catastrophe in history as described.
 
Last edited:
Not for the large majority. What you really need to accurately make claims in these circumstances is the equivalent to "same-store sales" used in retail, which I don't know if it exists out there, though it sounds difficult to obtain. But you can easily have GPD/capita rising for the majority while dragged overall down by new arrivals. That means there isn't the greatest economic catastrophe in history as described.
Yes, I think this is to some extent valid. We have added a lot of residents who are diluting the GDP per capita of the general population coming as students and being underemployed as gig workers etc. I don't think this is enough to explain the underperformance in Canada since ~2019.
 

Quebec premier threatens 'referendum' on immigration if Trudeau fails to deliver​

The Canadian Press
Updated April 9, 2024 5:20 p.m. EDT
Published April 9, 2024 4:09 p.m. EDT

Quebec Premier François Legault on Tuesday ratcheted up pressure on the federal government to reduce the number of temporary immigrants in the province, threatening to hold a "referendum" on the issue.

Legault told reporters that launching a plebiscite isn't in his government's short-term plans, but he suggested that could change if Prime Minister Justin Trudeau doesn't deliver on Quebec's immigration demands.

"Do we hold a referendum on this eventually? Do we do it more broadly, on other subjects? It will depend on the results of the discussions," Legault said at the legislature.

During a meeting between the two leaders in March, Trudeau rejected Legault's call for the Quebec government to have full powers over who can immigrate to the province. But Legault said the prime minister showed a significant amount of "openness" on other matters related to immigration and that the two would meet again by June 30.

"Don't forget, Mr. Trudeau promised me a new meeting by June 30, so I expect results," Legault said Tuesday.

The premier said the 560,000 temporary immigrants in Quebec — a number he said includes asylum seekers, temporary foreign workers and international students — are straining social services and putting the French language at risk. And he says the vast majority of Quebecers agree with him.

"What I want to tell Mr. Trudeau is that the majority of Quebecers think that 560,000 temporary immigrants, it's too much," Legault said.

The immigration debate has been long-standing between the two governments. Earlier this year, the premier wrote to Trudeau about the influx of asylum seekers entering Quebec. In recent years, the province has welcomed a disproportionate share, including more than 65,000 of the 144,000 would-be refugees who came to Canada last year.

Quebec has demanded Ottawa reimburse $1 billion — the amount the province says it has cost to care for asylum seekers over the last three years. The two governments agreed to create a working group to study Quebec's demands.

Legault said Quebec's leverage in negotiations is to get the "support" of the population, adding that whether he will trigger a referendum on the issue depends on whether Trudeau gives the province more powers over the immigration file. Legault did not give details about the potential questions Quebecers would be asked to vote on.

Quebec already controls the number of economic immigrants to the province, but it shares responsibility with Ottawa over refugees, newcomers who arrive through the family reunification stream and temporary foreign workers.

After the mid-March meeting, Legault said the prime minister was open to giving Quebec more power, including by requiring temporary foreign workers to be approved by the province before they can move there. If Quebec can pre-approve foreign workers then it can ensure they speak French and their numbers can be controlled, Legault has said, describing pre-approvals as a sort of "veto power."

 

Back
Top