News   GLOBAL  |  Apr 02, 2020
 9.5K     0 
News   GLOBAL  |  Apr 01, 2020
 40K     0 
News   GLOBAL  |  Apr 01, 2020
 5.4K     0 

hoggytime

Senior Member
Staff member
Member Bio
Joined
Dec 7, 2023
Messages
1,193
Reaction score
797
Previous Thread on SSP Ottawa

Description:
On May 16, 2022, Team 8003, Zeidler Architecture Inc. (Toronto, Canada) in association with David Chipperfield Architects (London, United Kingdom), was named the winner of the architectural design competition for Block 2.

Government of Canada names winner in Block 2 design competition

The design from Zeidler Architecture Inc. in association with David Chipperfield Architects. (Click the image to view enlarged version.)

Description provided by the team:
“Our proposal weaves together old and new to create a rich tapestry of past, present, and future. In the spirit of responsible stewardship, existing structures are given fresh purpose. The value of this built heritage is unlocked by a new net-zero building and public spaces that represent a bold new architectural expression of Canadian identity.”

Project Website

Architect Project Websites:
David Chipperfield
Zeidler

Renders:

Screenshot 2024-09-25 184204.png

Screenshot 2024-09-25 184245.pngScreenshot 2024-09-25 184236.pngScreenshot 2024-09-25 184230.pngScreenshot 2024-09-25 184223.pngScreenshot 2024-09-25 184215.png

 
From the Ottawa Sun:

Ottawa commuters' next headache: A massive redevelopment opposite Parliament Hill​

Federal government asks Ottawa's permission to block lanes on Wellington, O'Connor and Metcalfe streets for its redevelopment of Block 2.

Author of the article:
Blair Crawford
Published Sep 25, 2024 • Last updated 1 hour ago • 2 minute read

Block 2 redevelopment


Zeidler Architecture Inc. of Toronto and David Chipperfield Architects of London, England, were the winners of a design competition for the Block 2 redevelopment. A rendering shows the winning design. Photo by Government of Canada /.

The federal government is asking the city’s permission to block lanes on Wellington, O’Connor and Metcalfe streets — possibly for years — for its massive redevelopment opposite Parliament Hill.

The makeover of “Block 2”, which sits literally in the shadow of the Peace Tower and has been called “the most prestigious property in Canada,” will also include a tunnel network connecting Parliament’s East, West and Centre blocks to parliamentary offices on the south side of Wellington Street. Some 40 per cent of Parliament employees, including the Prime Minister’s Office itself, are on the south side of Wellington.

Block 2 is a nearly 80,000-square-metre block bounded by Wellington, O’Connor, Sparks and Metcalfe streets that forms the fourth and final side of Canada’s Parliament Square. In May 2022, the government announced that Zeidler Architecture Inc. of Toronto and David Chipperfield Architects of London, England, were the winners of a design competition for the redevelopment.

At the time, the government said the project would cost $430 million and it expected to start work by the fall of 2024. The cost of the project has reportedly ballooned to nearly $1 billion.

The tunnel network, a portion of which has already been completed during the renovations of West Block and the new visitors’ centre, will “ensure the safe and efficient movement of parliamentarians and materials in support of Parliamentary operations,” according to Public Services and Procurement Canada.

PSPC is expected to make its pitch for partial road closures to Ottawa’s transportation committee on Thursday, with one lane closed on O’Connor and Metcalfe streets and two of Wellington’s four lanes to be cordoned off.

Wellington Street was completely closed to traffic for more than a year after the February 2022 convoy occupation of the downtown core, and the city and the federal government have been talking ever since about who should control the street.

In December 2022, the House of Commons Standing Committee on Procedure and House Affairs recommended the Parliamentary Precinct be expanded to include Wellington and Sparks streets to improve security, and that Wellington be closed to traffic between Elgin and Kent streets.

In May 2023 briefing notes, PSPC said the government wants Wellington closed to vehicles and redeveloped as “a civic gathering space for celebration, national mourning and peaceful protest — a welcoming, open, safe and secure space for residents and visitors alike, befitting a major national capital.”

Mayor Mark Sutcliffe said last month that he met with members of cabinet in 2023 about potentially transferring the roadway to federal control, including a letter with a “draft framework,” but after a federal cabinet shuffle the issue appears to have been put on the back burner.

Since then, while the subject has “come up in passing,” Sutcliffe said there have “been no meaningful discussions” with the federal government on Wellington Street.

“I don’t want to have a conversation with the federal government about one street and just do a transaction on that, I want to have a conversation about the entire downtown and what we plan for downtown together, and Wellington can be a part of that,” Sutcliffe told reporters.
 
One error in the article is that Wellington is actually 5 lanes wide in that block, not 4. I think they will be able to keep a lane going in each direction, but making any turns from Wellington will be difficult. And the decision to put an interim bike lane (which is not used much, and often improperly) complicates things.
 
Honestly handing over all of downtown Ottawa to NCC/the feds sounds like an excellent idea. The city of Ottawa clearly has no interest in maintaining a good public realm and lacks the vision and ambition necessary for a G7 capital.

The contrast in public realm procurement quality between the NCC and the City of Ottawa is pretty jarring.
 
That's true to an extent, but on the other hand the NCC sometimes forgets that people need to live the parts of their lives that don't involve conspicuous citizening around on a bicycle. So the city builds something like Lansdowne, asks us to take the bus there, and the NCC wants to close one of two roads the goes past. Having two levels of local government with different priorities and philosophies has its challenges. Wellington is one of them.
 
The site has been fenced off:

IMG_2077.jpeg


I take Wellington almost daily and there are always plenty of cyclists using the bike lanes despite the haphazard design and poor connectivity to other cycling infrastructure in every direction.

I find it crazy that there is still this belief by some that cycling is only for recreation (which is how the comment above reads) when it’s obvious that people rely on it for all sorts of practical purposes (commuting, groceries, transport to entertainment etc.). Year on year you see more and more people taking advantage of the cycling infrastructure in the city thanks in part to an improved network and safer infrastructure.
 
That’s a few less sq/ft of space that the convoy idiots will be able to hang out in (and one of their favourite spots at that). Nice.
 
I find it crazy that there is still this belief by some that cycling is only for recreation (which is how the comment above reads) when it’s obvious that people rely on it for all sorts of practical purposes (commuting, groceries, transport to entertainment etc.). Year on year you see more and more people taking advantage of the cycling infrastructure in the city thanks in part to an improved network and safer infrastructure.

This is 100% true, and the people relying on it include kids who can't drive and lots of seniors (who allegedly are unable to cycle). The increase is impressive considering the terrible job the city has done with connectivity (just try to get from this project to the bike lane on O'Connor) and with putting even a little care into detours when they close bike lanes, which they seem to do a few times a month.

Surprised this one is moving so fast. Would be nice to see some type of coordination with the Parliament Hill project so you don't have overlapping construction on that corridor.
 
Looking back at the renders, the street presence at the corner of Metcalfe is going to suck. I get that it’s an almost perfect design if you want to mitigate bomb attacks, but wtf. It’s a literal stone wall fortress looming over the sidewalk.

Also, the addition to the buildings on the Metcalfe/Sparks side, to increase their height, looks kind of cheap and neither complements nor mirrors the existing buildings.
 
We can't ever expect new construction for the center of government to correspond to our notions of what is an engaging street presence in other realms. Not the way people feel entitled to behave towards elected representatives nowadays. A trumpist mob stormed the US Capitol and a trucker mob seized Wellington. MPs are harassed on a regular basis. We are lucky that the Hill is as accessible as it is. If Wellington is converted to a pedestrian plaza it will be empty except for a few cyclists 364 days a year because there is and will be nothing there causing anyone to linger. The existing sidewalks are already wider than they need to be, though I'm not advocating for narrowing them. Converting the area for light rail would bring people there, but they'd be a few blocks from where they actually want to be in most cases.

By the way, I'm not against bike lanes at all. My point about the NCC is that it is not responsible for spheres of our lives that other levels of government are, and doesn't always seem to care that people have to live in Ottawa when they aren't having some sort of Capital Experience. Closing the parkways on weekends is on balance a good thing, but there are some real transportation problems in the Glebe that closing the QED exacerbates because development has occurred on the assumption that its 2 lanes are open to traffic.
 
Is the Four Corners (Metcalfe and Wellington) closed? That building was rehabilitated only a few years ago. I hope they don't add any floors to the existing heritage buildings; seems like a good place to value engineer.
 
This is the rendering originally released.

1730204497703.jpeg



It amounts to taking off the existing mansard cap, which is not original, and adding two stories, one with gables. It looks a little awkward but the goal seems to be to achieve a large consistent top level for the east end. I don't think we've seen any subsequent renderings. It wouldn't surprise me if there were some refinements to this bit.
 
The photo from the Parks Canada Page for the building has a 1980s car in it, and may date from the designation in 1986.

1730220159766.jpeg


A nice little YouTube video about the building (81 seconds very well wasted!) starts off with this historical picture, the only one I can find online with the gables, which is undated and is probably not the original look. Those carriages are harder to date than the car.

1730221194136.png


The Parks Canada page refers to "a mansard roof pierced by eyebrow windows and decorated with iron cresting" which is not we see in any of the pictures, and it seems a little vague if this was originally a three- or four-story building, but it probably four. Now it's growing to five, possibly with some sort of mechanical layer between 3 and 4. It turns out there was originally a mansard, which must have inspired the topper Chipperfield came up with for the scheme.
 
Is the Four Corners (Metcalfe and Wellington) closed? That building was rehabilitated only a few years ago. I hope they don't add any floors to the existing heritage buildings; seems like a good place to value engineer.

Can confirm that the space is empty now
 

Back
Top