Tewder
Senior Member
As ProjectEnd has already pointed out there are many interesting ways to combine boxes together to create an interesting design. A building doesn't have to just be a box.
Good materials will make this one of the better buildings put up during this boom. Crappy materials will make it another Uptown. I'm obviously hoping for the latter.
can someone explain to me what people are criticizing (the upper portion, middle, lower, the whole thing, materials, etc..) ?
Well I think this is a fantastic building for Yaletown or MCC, but Toronto? I think we've moved on beyond the 2002 school of design.
The critique is that it's a cluttered mess, a grab bag of contradictory architectural tics and retreads, and that it therefore fits right in with the new parvenu neighbours - the dithery collection of boxes that is London on the Esplanade, the generic-faux-plus-extruded-Modernist-core that is Berczy, and 1 King West - where a decent enough core peeks out of a dimpled and snaggle-toothed cloak of precast that's supposed to echo the old bank building it is attached to, but doesn't.
Apart from that it is lovely, just lovely.
So it's post-Modern?The critique is that it's a cluttered mess, a grab bag of contradictory architectural tics and retreads, and that it therefore fits right in with the new parvenu neighbours - the dithery collection of boxes that is London on the Esplanade, the generic-faux-plus-extruded-Modernist-core that is Berczy, and 1 King West - where a decent enough core peeks out of a dimpled and snaggle-toothed cloak of precast that's supposed to echo the old bank building it is attached to, but doesn't.
The critique is that it's a cluttered mess, a grab bag of contradictory architectural tics and retreads, and that it therefore fits right in with the new parvenu neighbours - the dithery collection of boxes that is London on the Esplanade, the generic-faux-plus-extruded-Modernist-core that is Berczy, and 1 King West - where a decent enough core peeks out of a dimpled and snaggle-toothed cloak of precast that's supposed to echo the old bank building it is attached to, but doesn't.
Apart from that it is lovely, just lovely.