KhalilHeron
Active Member
I don't think these are on here anywhere
- Thread starter Northern Light
- Start date
Northern Light
Superstar
From whence did you fetch these?
IF they're newer than the old ones, it means they actually listened to some things I said (specific enough to see my finger prints)
I suggested this ceiling style, I did not suggest the undulation in it mind you!
I also suggested toning down the garish colours in the initial renders; though I didn't mean to have them just make it all white.
KhalilHeron
Active Member
https://www.ttc.ca/about-the-ttc/pr...cts/Bloor-Yonge-Station-Capacity-Improvements
The colours in the original renders were definitely a bit much. I agree this could use something other than white but I think the pop of colour on the floor showing door placement is a simple fun way to make things more interesting.
I do like the ceiling quite a bit, so thanks
dad pad
New Member
I understand there is no funding for it but seeing renderings of this project without platform screen doors will always be a bit of a letdown, in my opinion.
AlvinofDiaspar
Moderator
Not a huge fan of the curvy ceiling slats - it felt unoriginal and gratuitous (frankly it looks like knockoff Calatrava). DO like the attempt to opening up the ceiling to reduce increase the feel of the ceiling height though.
All that white will be a challenge to keeping clean - anything less than perfect will look shabby.
Even the province didn't go this route with their own builds - with good reasons.
AoD
All that white will be a challenge to keeping clean - anything less than perfect will look shabby.
Even the province didn't go this route with their own builds - with good reasons.
AoD
Last edited:
Northern Light
Superstar
My suggestion took inspiration from Union (subway) station; and was in contrast to the terrible matt finish metallic panels they are using as standard in their renos at the moment. I also suggested the need to try to raise the ceilings for both air flow and a less claustrophobic appearance.
Agreed.
TossYourJacket
Senior Member
While I get not everyone liked the amount of colour in the initial design, completely removing the intuitive wayfinding element they provided is very disappointing. Something in the middle would have been better but nope, we get no colour at all. Form over function I guess.
Northern Light
Superstar
The cost of PED's for this station is a rounding error on the budget. Email the Mayor, the TTC Chair etc. and make sure they know, you know!
Total cost for PEDs, at this station, with some contingency is ~30M
Total budget for this project, 1.5B
So we're talking about 2% of the budget, tops.
I can tell you there is a fairly large contingency on this project, at this stage, as in more than 10x that number.
It's very do-able.
Last edited:
daniel_kryz
Active Member
I agree. I don't like the bland & copy-cat feel of the ceiling. The overall aesthetic is boring and feels like it could be anywhere.
Union's ceiling and walls are much better. It is, in my opinion, a bare minimum of what stations should look like. I would prefer more creative interior design but, if Union's design is replicated, I can accept that.
These renderings lack elegance and I'm not happy with the exposed ceiling. I just wish there was a survey I could fill out, but clearly there hasn't been any public engagement despite this project's significance.
afransen
Senior Member
Yes, with ATC, I don't see any reason why we would be undertaking and major station reconstruction without PSD.
Voltz
Senior Member
I'm sure they could come up with a reason, like wanting to wait until they get new trains on Line 2, or deciding to lengthen the TR trains, In each case the doors might not line up.
rbt
Senior Member
The best argument is Bloor/Yonge is a terrible place to run an experiment where failure impacts service. The first PSD installation should be something like Highway 407 station as bypassing it impacts few customers.
Northern Light
Superstar
AlvinofDiaspar
Moderator
If they are going to use curving ceiling slats, it should done with purpose - to visually guide riders (platforms-escalators-exits). Done well it might even be more effective than signage.
AoD
AoD
AlbertHWagstaff
Senior Member
Until six months after the reno is complete, several of the fins will be removed for water leak remediation in random locations around the station and it'll look that way for at least two-three years until they get replaced and different fins get taken out leaving a gap-tooth ceiling. That's the normal Toronto subway aesthetic.