Agreed. 10 or 15 mins is not huge at all....and you get some exercise out of it
The appeal of these buildings is being close to the water, Ontario Place, Molson Amphitheater and CNE (all within 2-5 mins walking distance).
I disagree 100%. Ontario Place, the Amphitheatre and the CNE do nothing to add to the liveability of this neighbourhood – in fact they act as barriers that mark the boundaries of the neighbourhood. They are venues that you might attend a few times a year, and draw attendance from all over the city, but are of little use to the people who live nearby on an everyday basis.
As well, 15 minutes (30 both ways) is a long time to walk for basic shopping or to go grab a coffee or beer after work. After all, people who live in the suburbs are often only a 15 minute walk from the nearest drugstore or supermarket.
Finally, this neighbourhood has no centre. There’s no place for people to simply go, mingle, and be a community. Typically downtown Toronto neighbourhoods are based around long, linear streets (often running east-west) that serve as commercial centres with residential spaces to the north and south (e.g. QSW, Little Italy, Annex, etc). Given the awkward setup of this neighbourhood (CNE cutting it off to the west, the Gardner to the north and east, and the airport to the south), I don't think the typical "main street" central district is workable. Lakeshore and Queens Quay are too short, and Lakeshore is way too wide.
I think a reasonable alternative would be to concentrate retail/commercial activity right at the geographical centre of the neighbourhood and at a density commensurate to that of the surrounding condominiums. That’s why a multi-floor, urban shopping centre would be ideal. Of course, how often does the ideal actually play out in urban development? The corner of Queens Quay and Bathurst will probably just get another condo, and the entire neighbourhood will have to be satisfied with the retail equivalent of those spindly trees that struggle to grow on Toronto’s sidewalks.
I threw this image together. Blue is the major residential zones in the area, and the red represents the best place for a commercial centre.