junctionist
Senior Member
The setback is great given the location next to the Royal Alex. I like it because it allows for a spacious patio, as well as a place for people to socialize. The reflecting pool sounds redundant given the one across the street at Metro Square and not really compatible with the idea of the space as a social space. In fact, it almost sounds like there's too much space to work with.
The tower itself is short of being iconic. To be iconic requires more originality in form rather than tacking on panels. Absolute is iconic. So is City Hall. The T-D Centre has Mies van der Rohe's iconic black minimalist aesthetic on a scale that makes it unique in the world. Fortunately, this tower doesn't have to be iconic, but it should to be bold and memorable. What we have is a great looking design that will fit into this high-profile location nicely.
This tower needs to be built to this design without compromises down to the granite forecourt. The only other concern I have is about the south facade that faces King Street. It would have been better if the front of tower was more striking in design because it's also going to be prominently visible from Metro Square across the street. Most people in the square will probably be able to see some of the west side of the tower with the diagonal panels, but it would have been more interesting to make the front more exciting than just a series of balconies with horizontal white stripes of varying widths.
The tower itself is short of being iconic. To be iconic requires more originality in form rather than tacking on panels. Absolute is iconic. So is City Hall. The T-D Centre has Mies van der Rohe's iconic black minimalist aesthetic on a scale that makes it unique in the world. Fortunately, this tower doesn't have to be iconic, but it should to be bold and memorable. What we have is a great looking design that will fit into this high-profile location nicely.
This tower needs to be built to this design without compromises down to the granite forecourt. The only other concern I have is about the south facade that faces King Street. It would have been better if the front of tower was more striking in design because it's also going to be prominently visible from Metro Square across the street. Most people in the square will probably be able to see some of the west side of the tower with the diagonal panels, but it would have been more interesting to make the front more exciting than just a series of balconies with horizontal white stripes of varying widths.