Meikkhaell
Active Member
Was reading this article this morning, looking at some possible UFA goaltenders to sign as a backup or 1A/1B with Rittich.
As much as Smitty's playoff effort was spectacular, and as much as I like McElhinney, I feel like our best option out of those three would be Talbot.
And that's not just because it would be fun to watch angry Oilers fans as their team gets dumpstered by him in a Flames uniform. He's 32, and apart from this past season he has been a very good goalie across his entire career. He's had experience as both a backup and a starter, whereas Smitty seems like he'd much rather be "the guy," and Mac is a career backup. With Talbot, I feel like you could give him 30 games, or you could give him 60 games, depending on how Rittich is doing, and he would succeed either way. Since he had a down year he probably won't be super expensive, in contrast to Mac who just helped take the Canes to the ECF. He's also 4-5 years younger than Smith and McElhinney, so we could have a solid goaltending tandem locked in for quite a while.
If we could sign Rittich for $3-4M and Talbot for $2-3M, that's all our goaltending needs covered. Keep in mind, Fleury alone makes $7M, Lundqvist makes $8.5M, Price makes $10.5M. This could be a really good deal.
As much as Smitty's playoff effort was spectacular, and as much as I like McElhinney, I feel like our best option out of those three would be Talbot.
And that's not just because it would be fun to watch angry Oilers fans as their team gets dumpstered by him in a Flames uniform. He's 32, and apart from this past season he has been a very good goalie across his entire career. He's had experience as both a backup and a starter, whereas Smitty seems like he'd much rather be "the guy," and Mac is a career backup. With Talbot, I feel like you could give him 30 games, or you could give him 60 games, depending on how Rittich is doing, and he would succeed either way. Since he had a down year he probably won't be super expensive, in contrast to Mac who just helped take the Canes to the ECF. He's also 4-5 years younger than Smith and McElhinney, so we could have a solid goaltending tandem locked in for quite a while.
If we could sign Rittich for $3-4M and Talbot for $2-3M, that's all our goaltending needs covered. Keep in mind, Fleury alone makes $7M, Lundqvist makes $8.5M, Price makes $10.5M. This could be a really good deal.