Go Elevated or try for Underground?

  • Work with the province and go with the Elevated option

    Votes: 29 76.3%
  • Try another approach and go for Underground option

    Votes: 6 15.8%
  • Cancel it altogether

    Votes: 1 2.6%
  • Go with a BRT solution

    Votes: 2 5.3%

  • Total voters
    38
Yeah - just trying to save utility relocation - relocation. But as you suggest - 10th might be a better route (I’m so torn on all the options west of GCS). 🙃
And there is no time to deliberate.

Thanks for the info CT & BC.
 
Last edited:
If the line is going to be elevated over 10av, does it really matter if there are utils under the pavement?

Supports for the guideway could be built on the sidewalks if utils are under the road, or a centered support column could be used for the guideway if the utils happen to be under the sidewalks.

Either way, doesn't really seem like it should be a showstopper? Fingers crossed, those utils don't need to be rerelocated...

While I do like the elevated concept more and more, what's bothering me now with the proposed line as it stands is the price for phase 1.

7bil and change is going to make a big dent in finances for a while, and I can't help feeling the NC leg will be a long ways out..

What I'd like to see is a cost estimate for extending the elevated option across the river, into the hill with the 16av underground station, and far enough past to surface and go elevated again, stopping at the 28av or 40av station.

That way the big big spend covers the core of the system, and further extensions for both SE and NC can be done station at a time, rather than as big multi-billion megaprojects.

If that can be done for 10 bil or less, I say go for it!

If not, I vote setway for the SE until construction costs get... recalibrated.
 
Thinking about the NC expansion - and I think the key to getting this done will rest on the airport connection and the provinces grand central idea. An airport connection with transfers to Banff is really only great for tourism if it takes the green line right through downtown. Over to the Blue and then transfer to the green - not sure if that is enough of a deal breaker to have the airport connection, and NC linked together.

Just an idea.
 

Back
Top