TOareaFan
Superstar
The VIA $20 fare Brampton-Union is based on the minimum fare VIA charges. There are some who take the Brampton-Union trip, but most are either on commuter passes, those VIA-GO paks (I've used these sometimes) or are connecting to other trains. I've rode VIA on that trip with the paks (it was partly to boost my VIA Preference standing and save time, and they worked with GO student 10-rides and passes too!). I believe Georgetown is the same fare, though Guelph is somewhat higher. Also consider that VIA is subsidized (as is just about any mode of travel one way or another). Another benefit I found was that the train coming into Toronto in the morning also had the VIA 1 car open to coach passengers.
Yes, when I ride VIA it is always with one of the GO-VIA packs......it still makes the VIA train roughly double (+/-) the cost of GO and still shows that all services have a cost/comfort/convenience relationship matrix built into their pricing.
I don't think that VIA's minimum fare (which is not designed to attract close-range commuters, it is just part of their national price structure) is the same case as Blue 22 and isn't really comparable. At least there's also the option of GO from Brampton, something that your beloved Blue 22 won't have competing against it.
Not sure where you got the idea that Blue 22 is my "beloved".....all I have said in the past (and continue to say) is that as I understand the current proposal it is not a bad compromise.
That is that there are multiple options for getting to the airport and each will have its own cost/comfort/convenience matrix to consider:
1. Cabs/Cars.....most expensive, most comfortable, most convenient.......least predictable travel time.
2. Blue 22.....next expensive, direct, comfortable and very predictable travel time
3. GO Transit....next expensive, direct to a connector station (woodbine or Malton) with connector (like others I see no reason not to experiment with this now by extending the rail service to Malton with awaiting GO buses into the terminals).
4. TTC.......current service by bus has many more stops, less comfortable and less predictable travel time (due to mingling with cars/traffic) but significantly cheaper (+/- half of #3, 10% of number 2)
Of course there are others (non ttc/GO buses, GO buses from Yorkdale/York Mills, walking) and you could fit them in above.....also VIA but their frequency is pretty low on this line but they would fit between 2 & 3 above.
The point is "my beloved" (as you call it) Blue 22 will always have to compete on a cost/comfort/convenience (ie. value) basis with other methods of getting to the airport.....as it should.