Definitely important to remember what the building they started with looked like. It was a difficult canvas to start with, but they at least selected a good palette and you can tell that some thought went into the materials used.
I thought the proportions looked weird in the DP renderings, but this still turned out better than I expected, mainly because they improved the layout of the staircases.
The fact that they were able to open up half of the ground floor by removing a significant amount of fill is a win in my mind. The elevation of the north side of the street to the sidewalk isn’t very inviting pretty much all along 34th from this point east, yet they’ve managed to make both the ground floor and second floor pretty inviting.