archited
Senior Member
I am sorry -- I am completely underwhelmed! There is no leadership shown here -- meek copies of elements seen in other cities. Leaving this kind of planning to an internal City planning group is entirely the wrong way to go. There is no connection to the businesses along the way; actually there is only tenuous connection to any of the street uses and none are advanced in any meaningful way. Ideas: 1. lose the speedway concept for Jasper. Reduce the total number of lanes to 3 in total, changeable at rush hour to two in the pertinent direction and one opposing. 2. Get rid of the turn left lanes altogether (let cars turn right and right and right to get to the opposite side of the street -- this has proven to be a very successful strategy in Santa Barbara on the main street -- State Street). 3. let the lanes veer to allow for centre-lane bus stops at every second block (maximum -- and at mid-block instead of block ends -- leads to better traffic control). 4. raise pedestrian crosswalks to sidewalk grade with gently sloped approaches for vehicles (acts as a traffic speed modulator). 5. allow illuminated business signage overhead in the pedestrian right of way (creates more intense interest, encourages more business street participation, doubles as pedestrian-scale lighting -- far more interesting than kitschy catalogue-selected lamp styles). 6. rent the sidewalk space to adjacent businesses requiring them to submit a well-developed plan for its use and maintenance -- maintaining a clear pedestrian path through the projected use. 7. Employ snow/frost-free paving for both the pedestrian realm and the vehicle realm (there are numerous options here -- Edmonton should be a leader in this category) 8. create vertical plant-wall spaces that define the street. 9. create banner-hanging mechanisms over the motor vehicle portion of the street (double as street lighting). 10. create a two-way bike lane protected from motor vehicle traffic (also paved to maintain snow-free status). 11. micro-zone the storefronts to place eateries on block ends and mid block (adjacent to pedestrian crosswalks) and remove non-retail businesses from the street level (insurance companies, law and accounting offices, medical clinics, service outlets -- none of these businesses enhance street life) 12. create varied and intense landscape buffers along the street separating vehicles from other street uses 13. visual is one aspect for the senses -- create sound islands and make spaces for street buskers along the route 14. Allow for some cross-Avenue canopies (various materials -- glass, fabric, projection screens), particularly at the mid-block bus stops mentioned earlier (these again could be revenue generators for advertising as well as venues to promote the City) 15. remove automobile parking from the main street altogether and provide bicycle parking corrals on side streets 16. allow retail outlets to bring their wares to sidewalk displays.
I could go on for days with suggestions that would help liven the pedestrian street. What has been presented is VERY disappointing. It engenders the same kind of "miss" that happened with the Armature in the Quarters section of the City. Somebody -- somehow -- has to get through to the City before they spend another whopping pile of money to no good end!
I could go on for days with suggestions that would help liven the pedestrian street. What has been presented is VERY disappointing. It engenders the same kind of "miss" that happened with the Armature in the Quarters section of the City. Somebody -- somehow -- has to get through to the City before they spend another whopping pile of money to no good end!