|
|
|
These are not the same thing.
Generally, in the US, outside money is considered to be a problem in their democracy. Here people are clamouring for the right of interest groups to exercise influence through money.
The mayor’s unusual request blindsided his colleagues.
In October, Vaughan Mayor Maurizio Bevilacqua sprung resolutions on his council to approve three special zoning orders that would allow the province to expedite construction projects some of his fellow council members say they knew nothing about.
The developments would be fast-tracked through minister’s zoning orders, or MZOs, a controversial and blunt tool used sparingly for decades that is now being wielded with alarming frequency by the Ford government.
Skip Advertisement
Two of the MZO requests put forward by Bevilacqua were for projects that could add close to 10,000 housing units, and the third for a warehouse on provincially protected land, normally off-limits to developments.
All three, as council members found out later, were associated with the Cortelluccis, a prominent family of land developers based in Vaughan.
“We have never done it this way,” said local councillor Marilyn Iafrate, who unsuccessfully pushed back on the requests, asking for public hearings before making a decision. “No applications, no staff reports, no public hearings. Zero. It was basically like ‘This is what we want. Approve it.’ ”
Once approved, the MZO request goes to the Ontario government. And with Doug Ford at the helm, it’s high season for fast orders. One of the MZOs approved by Vaughan council last Oct. 21 was granted by the province 16 days later — a decision that can’t be appealed.
The Ford government has handed out 44 permanent MZOs since 2019. Last year alone, it issued 33 — more than twice as many as the previous government did in 15 years.
Ontario’s prolific use of the zoning tool has upturned a decades-old planning system that had specific processes, protections and transparency built into it, say critics of MZOs, including residents, local councillors and MPPs. And in turn, it has created a system that appears to be less about procedure but more about who you know.
The Ford government says these zoning orders are being used to benefit the people of Ontario. However, a Torstar investigation shows they are increasingly benefiting a select group of prominent land developers with strong ties to municipal leaders and the Ontario PC party.
Iafrate wasn’t the only councillor who wondered what was going on when Mayor Bevilacqua proposed three MZOs.
“Why one (developer) over the other?” said councillor Sandra Yeung Racco. “Is it because they have donated, do we have to treat them differently?”
A little more than a year before Bevilacqua introduced the three MZO requests, the Cortellucci family made a $40-million donation to the new hospital in Vaughan that now carries their name. They also donated millions to the city’s first hospice and university campus, on top of tens of thousands of dollars to candidates running for local council and even more to the Ontario Progressive Conservatives.
“An historical evening for the City of Vaughan,” Bevilacqua beamed when he announced the Cortelluccis’ hospital donation at a sold-out mayor’s gala featuring luxury cars on display and an opera singer. He shared a story about how his father, a newcomer to Canada 50 years ago, rented trucks to the Cortellucci family, who were also then starting out.
In attendance were local PC MPP Stephen Lecce and a tuxedoed Premier Doug Ford, who spoke highly of the family’s humility and generosity.
The mayor’s requests for MZOs alarmed a number of residents, too.
In February, they filed a complaint with the city’s integrity commissioner asking why Vaughan “should endorse MZOs at the expense of public consultation,” and “circumvent the local planning process and prioritize this developer’s application, ahead of all other active applications that followed and abided by the local planning process.”
The commissioner reviewed the “informal complaint” and said the mayor was in compliance with city rules. However, she said the process, if left unchecked, could cause council to become a “very permissive body,” allowing its members to act in their own self-interest “rather than in the interests of the municipality or the public.”
The mayor’s request would let the Cortelluccis queue-jump almost 500 other applications before the city that were following the normal planning processes, the complaint said.
Vaughan council passed the mayor’s request for the three MZOs, and the Ford government granted two of them. The third, which would see the removal of provincially significant wetland and forests if approved, is still pending.
It’s not known if the donations played any role in Vaughan council’s decision to ask for the MZOs or the province’s choice to approve them. There’s nothing illegal or improper about developers donating money to politicians and charitable causes.
Mayor Bevilacqua, who noted one of the developments aims to bring in needed public housing, said he acted in the public interest. He said he brought in the proposed MZOs at the request of his staff. “I am just one vote. If the council doesn’t endorse it, it doesn’t go anywhere,” he said. “Ultimately, the province will decide if they want to issue an MZO. I don’t make that decision.” He also said that not every hospital donor got an MZO.
MZOs take precedence over any local or regional council planning decisions. Only the province can hand them out or revoke them.
“We will never stop issuing MZOs for the people of Ontario, the people that need housing,” Ford said earlier this year.
Despite Ontario’s vast size, the Ford government has only issued MZOs in a core of the province that revolves around the GTA.
They have been used to approve a glass factory, giant warehouses, nursing homes and large subdivisions. They have authorized projects on provincial land, helped municipal governments add affordable housing and allowed non-profit groups to build seniors homes.
Of 44 MZOs issued in the past two years, 38 have gone to Toronto, the regions of York, Peel and Durham, and Simcoe County — some of the wealthiest parts of the province, where population growth is expected to jump in coming decades and land is most expensive.
...
This is from 2020, wonder if she subsequently pushed herself to the front of the vaccine queue??
This is from 2020, wonder if she subsequently pushed herself to the front of the vaccine queue??
Too bad there isn't a vaccine against stupidity.
AoD
But again, the vast majority of anti-vaxxers are pro-life and pro-abstinence.Contraception?
Though there are different kinds of "pro-life"--for instance, I reckon that a lot of anti-vaxx mommy bloggers constitute a more secular kind of "pro-life", if only because, as mommy bloggers, their children are their raison d'etre, they're advancing the more generic cause of motherhood through their own obsessive-compulsive reporting on their own practices in the name of motherhood. And thus those who abort or impede reproduction simply aren't on their radar. (And as far as pro-abstinence counts: I suspect a lot of mommy bloggers would rather their children remain forever children, because once they get into adolescence they get minds of their own, thus negating the mommy bloggers' purpose)But again, the vast majority of anti-vaxxers are pro-life and pro-abstinence.
What do you expect?Though there are different kinds of "pro-life"--for instance, I reckon that a lot of anti-vaxx mommy bloggers constitute a more secular kind of "pro-life", if only because, as mommy bloggers, their children are their raison d'etre, they're advancing the more generic cause of motherhood through their own obsessive-compulsive reporting on their own practices in the name of motherhood. And thus those who abort or impede reproduction simply aren't on their radar. (And as far as pro-abstinence counts: I suspect a lot of mommy bloggers would rather their children remain forever children, because once they get into adolescence they get minds of their own, thus negating the mommy bloggers' purpose)
Well, never mind Tiger Mothers; there's also a lot of more generic helicopter/snowplow parenting.What do you expect?
A CBC blogger once compared parents with dictators:
...and that's without mentioning Tiger Mothers.