"Rogers Centre" violates several renaming conventions.
One is the simple fact that a baseball stadium is typically never called a "Centre" - that is reserved for hockey/basketball arenas. They are always fields, domes, parks or stadia (Camden Yards is a exception).
Secondly, it is the complete renaming of a landmark that is famous for what it is. SkyDome, for better or worse, was considered by many to be a marvel - the epitome of the 1980s mega park projects.
Precedent - the Calgary Saddledome became the Canadian Airlines Saddledome, then the Pengrowth Saddledome. The name Saddledome stuck.
Rogers Centre erased any link to its former name that existed for 16 years in order, I presume, to quickly change the lexicon to force people to say "Rogers". Owning a sports channel and radio stations that immediately said "Rogers Centre" as much as it could in its traffic reports wouldn't hurt its cause.
Those reasons, plus the fact taxpayers were taken for a ride by Godfrey twice with the renaming, is why I will go to my grave without muttering the rename, unless to express the reasons why it is wrong.