Paclo

Paclo

Administrator
Staff member
Member Bio
Joined
Aug 25, 2020
Messages
2,845
Reaction score
13,540
This thread will be used for discussion of Kipling-Eglinton Station: a proposed below-grade TTC station on the Eglinton Crosstown (Line 5) West Extension, serving the intersection of Kipling Avenue and Eglinton Avenue West in Toronto's Richview Park neighbourhood.

Kipling-Eglinton-map.jpg
 
Adding the station entrance locations as shown in the presentation from Metrolinx:

Screenshot_20230423-085730.png


I've mentioned this in the past, but they really should have had the ECWE stations straddle the intersecting roads, and have a second entrance on the opposite side of intersecting roads. This negates the requirement for the north-south bus offloading passengers to cross the busy streets to get to the station entrance.

And I also prefer "Princess Gardens station".
 
I find both Kingsway and Princess Gardens to be inappropriate names for the station.

Princess Gardens sounds really nice, I'll not dispute that, but it is not a location that is known to most people - I am a lifelong road geek, map enthusiast, and I know the city well, and have never heard the locale referred to as such before. It appears neither in any street atlas of Toronto I have ever seen, nor is it shown on the city of Toronto's neighbourhood map - the area is filed under "Princess-Rosethorn", itself a fairly arcane designation.

The Kingsway is almost half a kilometre from the proposed station site and is about as helpful to wayfinding as calling St. Clair West station Vaughan.

Nay, the only logical name for the station is Kipling North.
 
T3G said:
I find both Kingsway and Princess Gardens to be inappropriate names for the station.

Princess Gardens sounds really nice, I'll not dispute that, but it is not a location that is known to most people - I am a lifelong road geek, map enthusiast, and I know the city well, and have never heard the locale referred to as such before. It appears neither in any street atlas of Toronto I have ever seen, nor is it shown on the city of Toronto's neighbourhood map - the area is filed under "Princess-Rosethorn", itself a fairly arcane designation.

The Kingsway is almost half a kilometre from the proposed station site and is about as helpful to wayfinding as calling St. Clair West station Vaughan.

Nay, the only logical name for the station is Kipling North.
Click to expand...
It's a 15-minute walk from the Pioneer Village Station on Line 1 to the Black Creek Pioneer Village. So, why not Kingsway Station, if distance is not a problem for Pioneer Village Station.
 
I don't think Pioneer Village was the correct name to choose for the station, Steeles West would've made more sense.

But just because a mistake was made before, doesn't mean we should make it again. Calling this station Kingsway would have zero wayfinding value, which is the sole purpose of a station or stop name.
 
T3G said:
I don't think Pioneer Village was the correct name to choose for the station, Steeles West would've made more sense.

But just because a mistake was made before, doesn't mean we should make it again. Calling this station Kingsway would have zero wayfinding value, which is the sole purpose of a station or stop name.
Click to expand...
Well, the main purpose is to have a unique identifier - which is why, for emergency purposes, Metrolinx is so fussed about not duplicating names. The secondary purpose is to hopefully provide an indication of where the station is located. This sometimes results in stations with names that are *not* helpful from a wayfinding perspective. I have been living in Toronto for decades, and it always takes me some time and a map to figure out where St Patrick and St Andrew are. But it's also totally fine, and not a significant barrier.
 
T3G said:
I find both Kingsway and Princess Gardens to be inappropriate names for the station.

Princess Gardens sounds really nice, I'll not dispute that, but it is not a location that is known to most people - I am a lifelong road geek, map enthusiast, and I know the city well, and have never heard the locale referred to as such before. It appears neither in any street atlas of Toronto I have ever seen, nor is it shown on the city of Toronto's neighbourhood map - the area is filed under "Princess-Rosethorn", itself a fairly arcane designation.

The Kingsway is almost half a kilometre from the proposed station site and is about as helpful to wayfinding as calling St. Clair West station Vaughan.

Nay, the only logical name for the station is Kipling North.
Click to expand...
And what happens if there's another station North of this one on Kipling? Cardinal directions + street names only works with very few transit lines (a maximum of 3 crossing any given street). While we have used this system in the past, in makes no sense anymore as we aggressively expand the transit system.
 
Nobody refers to this area as Princess Gardens. The entire stretch from Martin Grove to Royal York is collectively called Richview but for transit station purposes, that moniker will likely go to the Eglinton-Islington stop, as the high school is right at that intersection. Martin Grove Station will likely go to the stop at Martin Grove so that's also a non-starter.

Some variation of Widdicombe or Widdicombe Hill would be pretty suitable IMO as the street is just north of Eglinton and Widdicombe Hill Park is just NE of where the station will be situated.
 
Translude15 said:
Nobody refers to this area as Princess Gardens. The entire stretch from Martin Grove to Royal York is collectively called Richview but for transit station purposes, that moniker will likely go to the Eglinton-Islington stop, as the high school is right at that intersection. Martin Grove Station will likely go to the stop at Martin Grove so that's also a non-starter.

Some variation of Widdicombe or Widdicombe Hill would be pretty suitable IMO as the street is just north of Eglinton and Widdicombe Hill Park is just NE of where the station will be situated.
Click to expand...
Except that "Martin Grove" is being used (at the moment) for Line 6 Finch West LRT.

FinchWestLRT-Map-NOV-2018-ENGLISH_cu6apg.jpg
From link.
 
W. K. Lis said:
It's a 15-minute walk from the Pioneer Village Station on Line 1 to the Black Creek Pioneer Village. So, why not Kingsway Station, if distance is not a problem for Pioneer Village Station.
Click to expand...
Sorry, but Kingsway Station would be a bad name for this one. As has already been stated above, when you name drop "The Kingsway" into conversation, locals understand you're either talking about the shopping strip along Bloor on either side of Royal York Road, or the area north of it… or you don't know what you're talking about.

42
 
You must log in or register to post here.

Back
Top