By Kate McGillivray,
CBC News Posted: Sep 30, 2016 5:00 AM ET Last Updated: Sep 30, 2016 5:00 AM ET
By Thursday morning, the building had a number of walls knocked down. Its three distinctive chimney structures are still standing. (CBC)
A historic Mimico building was partially demolished Wednesday, despite a decision made that afternoon by the Toronto Preservation Board to recommend it be preserved under the Ontario Heritage Act.
The former factory, built in 1917, is owned by Freed Development, and signs at the site indicate plans to build five residential apartment buildings.
For most of its life, 1 Audley Street was a factory that produced sporting goods. (City of Toronto)
The building, located at 1 Audley Street near Royal York Road and Newcastle Street in south Etobicoke, had been on the city's radar as a historic property for at least a year, when Mimico historian Michael Harrison recommended it be earmarked for preservation.
"It's one of the earliest industrial buildings in Mimico that still exists," Harrison told CBC News. But he said historical value often doesn't stop buildings getting demolished.
"If they're not designated under the Ontario Heritage Act, they're not safe," he explained.
Not long after it was first built, the factory produced engine parts
But for much of its existence, the building was owned by the Schindler Company, which produced sporting good such as fishing line.
Chris Moore, president of the Mimico Residents Association, agrees with Harrison that the building should have been preserved.
"Every time I walk through there I've always enjoyed walking by that building. It just has a certain character that not much else has in the area," Moore said.
Building was weeks away from heritage status
The building at 1 Audley Street did go before the Preservation Board, but it still had to be approved by Etobicoke community council and Toronto city council before it could be designated an official heritage building.
"In cases where there is a potential imminent demolition it can become a race against time," said Mary MacDonald, senior manager in heritage preservation services for city planning.
In a statement to CBC News, Freed Development said it had received all the necessary permits for demolition.
"These activities were pursued with the full and complete permission of the City and in keeping with the permits that were granted," it read.
Historian Michael Harrison had hoped that the building could be saved. (CBC)
Harrison mourns the loss, and said he's already seen other historic Mimico buildings suffer the same fate.
"What they did was legally correct, and they had a demolition permit, but it was morally wrong," he said.
Commercial buildings especially vulnerable
In Toronto, it's commercial buildings that are more at risk for knee-jerk demolition.
Residential buildings that are considered to have possible historical value fall under a bylaw that protects them.
"You are required to post a notice, there's a period of time when objections can be raised, and if there are objections then the demolition of that building needs to be considered by community council," said MacDonald.
No equivalent process exists for commercial buildings, leading developers to rush to demolish before any designation is established.
For MacDonald, this conflict is part of larger struggle for communities in Toronto trying to preserve their past.
"When we see things disappearing, we understand what it means to the local community, and I feel really bad for the people in Mimico," she said.
