Toronto Star - Duncan sounds Ontario economic warning
'Tough times ahead' for province's economy, finance minister says, but not 'a big black hole'
Sep 30, 2008 04:30 AM
Rob Ferguson
Queen's Park Bureau
Ontarians should gird for "tough times ahead," Finance Minister Dwight Duncan warned as he released figures showing the economy shrank slightly in the first six months of the year, despite slight growth in the second quarter.
"There's more uncertainty than I would like as finance minister," Duncan acknowledged yesterday, as the U.S. financial crisis worsened.
But with his fall economic statement due Oct. 22, Duncan was coy when asked what spending will be trimmed as the government copes with lower revenues.
"Whatever restraint is necessary ... it will be fairly modest in the beginning," he said.
While his wording raised the spectre of deeper cuts, Duncan sought to reassure Ontarians.
"We're not looking at a big black hole. We're looking at adjustments in the economy," he told a hastily called news conference to announce the government's second-quarter financial results.
Duncan said Ontario's economy grew slightly, by 0.3 per cent, in the three months from April to June – a rebound from a decline of 0.4 per cent in the first quarter. Taken together, Ontario's economy shrank 0.1 per cent in the first half of the year.
Officials said the second-quarter rise was due to increases in business inventories, and household and business spending, although exports were lower with the manufacturing sector hard-hit by the higher dollar and U.S. slowdown.
Duncan added this is no time to bring in a carbon tax – something his federal Liberal cousins are proposing, with a carbon tax in their election platform.
"One of the things that I think would be a mistake right now is massive shifts in the tax burden at a time when there's uncertainty," he said.
The second-quarter gain means Ontario is not technically in a recession, defined as two consecutive quarters of decline, but Duncan said his biggest fear remains a "protracted" period of little or no growth in the economy.
"I take my cue from the people of Ontario and the people I talk to are nervous," he added.
But thousands of laid-off manufacturing workers feel like the province is in a recession, opposition critics said.
The Liberals need to do more to help the economy – such as tax cuts to spur business – than they've been doing with their five-point plan that includes more worker retraining, said Progressive Conservative finance critic Ted Chudleigh.
NDP Leader Howard Hampton said the Liberal government is "out of touch."