|
|
|
Sounds like the city is preparing to do improvements on 11St from 12th to Cameron Aves, anyone know what specifically they are going to be doing? I think it's a waste of money as long as 11St north of 12 Ave has super narrow sidewalks, unprotected bike lanes and the CPR tracks to deal with.
I think they picked the right section, the focus would be the extension of the bike lanes south beyond 12th Ave and a bunch of intersection improvements along the corridor, particularly to get bicycles across 17th Ave which is a big barrier now due to the weird signal configuration. 11 Street is actually a fairly heavy pedestrian route south of 12th Ave - although I would assume more locally-focused, rather than commuter-focused - particularly from 17th to the strip of heritage retail and the dog park between 15 and 14 Ave. The crossing on 13th Avenue is likely one of the busiest for pedestrians on that stretch (currently a blinker with no pedestrian bump outs), with school traffic and it being one of the best east-west walking routes (IMO aesthetically, traffic calming, safety) in the Beltline. The improvements sound to be mobility only - no street trees are likely. Looks like they are timing the construction for a road resurfacing, hence the focus of smaller spot improvements rather than a full rebuild.I hadn’t heard about the improvements, but I agree The improvements would be better suited between 12th Ave. and the Kirby LRT station. I don’t have any stats in front of me, but that seems to be where all the 11th street foot traffic is.
I guess I haven't been around the area south of 12th ave very much. I always thought it was rather quiet com pared to the section north of 12th. For me the big issue is the train tracks and having people wait around for trains to pass, or as we've seen in the past, people trying to cross while the train is stopped. It's only my personal opinion, but I'd rather see money go towards an underpass at 11th than sprucing up the section south of 12th....though as you mentioned it would probably be a lot more expensive to do the underpass.I think they picked the right section, the focus would be the extension of the bike lanes south beyond 12th Ave and a bunch of intersection improvements along the corridor, particularly to get bicycles across 17th Ave which is a big barrier now due to the weird signal configuration. 11 Street is actually a fairly heavy pedestrian route south of 12th Ave - although I would assume more locally-focused, rather than commuter-focused - particularly from 17th to the strip of heritage retail and the dog park between 15 and 14 Ave. The crossing on 13th Avenue is likely one of the busiest for pedestrians on that stretch (currently a blinker with no pedestrian bump outs), with school traffic and it being one of the best east-west walking routes (IMO aesthetically, traffic calming, safety) in the Beltline. The improvements sound to be mobility only - no street trees are likely. Looks like they are timing the construction for a road resurfacing, hence the focus of smaller spot improvements rather than a full rebuild.
Given all that, I can see why investing south of 12 Ave is the right call, while north of 12th is ugly and uncomfortable, it already operates as a strong multi-modal corridor with bike lanes established already. To get material improvements along that stretch would be awesome, but also would be much more serious business (e.g. grade separation of the CPR tracks), reduction of 9th Ave's signal priority, reconstruction of the whole right-of-way to make the sidewalks wider for street trees etc. Would be amazing if we could knock those improvements out - but will take way more effort/funding than what is proposed here (similar to the challenges getting 8 Street SW's corridor improvements moving as well).
Yeah I totally agree, the underpass would be a better bang for the buck, but with the major caveat being a much higher minimum investment. The types of things they mentioned south of 12th is likely a few million (excluding the already planned road resurfacing), the last inner city underpass we did was at 4 Street SE and came in at $70M in 2011. Put another way, if we saved 20 - 30 of investments of the scale of what they are talking about south of 12th you could buy 1 underpass. Would be a great project, but just will need to be funded from an entirely different mechanism that the community-scale minor improvements funding.I guess I haven't been around the area south of 12th ave very much. I always thought it was rather quiet com pared to the section north of 12th. For me the big issue is the train tracks and having people wait around for trains to pass, or as we've seen in the past, people trying to cross while the train is stopped. It's only my personal opinion, but I'd rather see money go towards an underpass at 11th than sprucing up the section south of 12th....though as you mentioned it would probably be a lot more expensive to do the underpass.