Dear Dilla,
Thank you for your message on the ratification of the negotiated agreement.
Contract negotiations are typically challenging, and the recent negotiations with CUPE 79 and 416 were no different. All sides started with a goal of finding the best possible deal through bargaining, and in the end, everyone found a fair compromise. I feel that this settlement strikes an appropriate balance that is both fair to the workers and affordable to the City. It was always our goal to reach a contract that would save jobs, protect services, and stay within the City’s budget.
Throughout the strike, I worked on constituency matters as well as helping to find a resolution to the labour disruption. The Employee and Labour Relations Committee oversaw the mandate for our negotiators. As Vice-Char of that Committee, I remained involved and updated on the progress of negotiations. Our City negotiating teams did an excellent job of working towards an agreement that fit the mandate set for them by Council's committee.
All of the City’s negotiations took place within this framework approved by the Committee. The negotiators were obliged to work within this mandate, and any deal that was struck had to stick within these parameters. Our negotiators were successful in reaching a deal that fit within these boundaries.
The City’s position that was presented near the beginning of the strike was only the starting point, with the intention of negotiating towards a deal that was agreeable to all sides and fair to the workers and affordable for the City. Had Council voted down the agreement, negotiations would have moved to arbitration, which would have likely cost the City more and would not have addressed the issue of the sick benefits.
The City did not back down on the issue of banking sick days. This program was established in the 1960s by provincial legislation in order to address the shortage of workers and attempt to encourage them to continue working when they were sick. Wrapping up this long-held provision was not easy and required appropriate compensation for those who had banked sick days.
At the beginning of negotiations, the union did not want to discuss the issue at all. The unions felt that the banking of sick days protected the workers during rare and prolonged injury and illness. They also felt that the pay-out before retirement ensured that workers do not needlessly use up the sick days. The City felt that the number of sick days and the ability to bank them did not treat all of the sectors fairly. Employees in some sectors, such as child care and EMS, require more sick days because the nature of their work, whereas office workers are less likely to get sick or injured and miss work.
Through negotiations, we were able to find a way to phase out the banking of sick days while protecting employees who were forced to miss work due to a short term illness or injury. The negotiated deal also brings in workers previously not covered by a regular allotment of sick days and encourages all workers to stay home when ill. The gradual end to the banking of sick days will help alleviate the liability that the City currently carries and has a number of flexible payout options that will appeal to employees. This new plan is projected to save the City over $140 million over the next six years.
The gradual phase out and payout of the plan is not unusual. In fact, this is standard practice in other jurisdictions at the federal, provincial, and municipal orders of government. This phase out ensures an easy transition that is affordable for the City and fair to the workers.
Although reaching an agreement was difficult, the City and the unions were able to work together to find a compromise that is reasonable for the union workers and the City, but just as important, is affordable to Torontonians, since they pay the bills. I am grateful for the hard work and long hours from the negotiators on both sides of the bargaining table, and I am confident that we will be able to move forward together and keep this city working for everyone.
Thank you, once again, for your message. This labour disruption had an impact on all Torontonians, and I am pleased that we have found a reasonable resolution.
Sincerely,
Pam