BASE said:
I'm not playing in the same league as the Clifton or any of the above but my take would be what you get with Clifton that you don't with those:

  • Have to believe the finishes are of the highest quality
  • Facing a much quieter street than any of the above
  • Maybe the biggest factor would be they are all high end units meaning less neighbors to deal with which in a situation with a strata could be very important for alignment. Clifton would be like living on a street full of mansions whereas the other buildings above might be like a street with a couple mansions, some single family homes, and some townhomes.
Most important point made is folks with the kind of wealth to afford places like these aren't simply looking at dollars per square foot.
Click to expand...
I would also add to this list: nearby amenities & safety

- Legends/Symphony struggle with a more CBD location with increased crime/homelessness. Almost none of this comparatively in 124th street area.
- West Block is getting pretty good, but only a handful of amenities in the base and still car dependent area mostly. Vs. Clifton has 10+ bars and nice restaurants within a 5min walk. Multiple clothing stores, art galleries, and cafes within 8mins.
- Proximity to glenora (for those who may live there already and are looking to move from bigger lot/yard to Condo) vs a farther move
- River valley views vs 104ave north views in Legends
- Agree on less residents too. Exclusiveness vs a 200+ unit building with more "average earners" in the 300-600k places.
 
No, don't work on their marketing team or have any connection with them! We can debate all we want, but the market will decide if the pricing is correct or not.

I do agree the location is an important part of this. We in Edmonton live in a bubble of relative affordability in a sea of affordability. So those people who are in this particular market, and probably more connected to pricing elsewhere, may not just be comparing this to a house price here.
 
Mattyeg said:
Agree with everything being said, but still missing the point that pricing at Clifton is unrealistic… I linked to the complete building sale simply as another metric to point out how off the pricing is. Do you guys work for the marketing team lol? Because your trying really hard to defend something that should be indefensible. So in this building your expected to pay 1-3million more to look at groat road and be Glendora adjacent?


2021spft on 20th floor of symphony for $989,900
3322spft on 53 floor of legends $3,100,000
Westblock unfinished penthouse for 2,249,000. Steal of a del compared to Clifton
And last but not least, a brand new listing
4107sqft One River Park 3.9mil
I know pearl tower has issues but still! 5196sqft! For 1.695mil!
Click to expand...
You decide its unrealistic pricing because you linked some comps lol? Sales by those who can afford + have chosen to buy have decided its not.

Beauty of market economics hey?
 
Oh sorry, did I miss the shovels in the ground announcement?

I’m not gonna bother commenting more until this project is cancelled :) see you then
 
Mattyeg said:
Oh sorry, did I miss the shovels in the ground announcement?

I’m not gonna bother commenting more until this project is cancelled :) see you then
Click to expand...
I don't see it being cancelled. Their sales were strong enough already and I suspect that maybe another unit sold should be enough to get shovels on the ground.
There may not be A LOT of market for things like this here, but certainly there is some, and it's very presumptuous to assume that there aren't enough buyers in a city this size, with how much money goes around here.
Again, there might not be many, but I could think of a few dozen people I know that, if they had the money, they'd buy it (me included), so I would expect that, amongst the people who already HAVE that kind of money, there are some who would be interested. Not everyone wants to be living in some of the places you mentioned previously, and a lot of the people with this kind of money don't really have a single property, anyways.
 
MacLac said:
I’d bet nickels to homeless people that Autograph has tailored this building to a group of buyers who have already expressed interest in purchasing
Click to expand...
cmd uw said:
The price is what the 'market' is willing to pay for it. It doesn't matter what price you, I or anyone else thinks is justifiable or not. The price makes sense to those who are signing the purchase contract. Over n' out.
Click to expand...
Completely concur.
As per pricing, who would want to spend 250 000 000.00 for a penthouse? that is what it costs in NYC's, so put that into perspective.
 
Nope. He didn't.

I think he is saying in a market like Edmonton where the average downtown condo is around $350K, it can be jarring for people to contemplate someone spending $5M+ on a unit...But that same exponential difference in value exists in every market, even NYC where the average condo price may be $2.5M but there are offerings on the market for $250M.
 
You must log in or register to post here.

Back
Top