I thought Paikin did a decent job for the most part (certainly better than Mansbridge, who didn't seem half as informed as the average UT member). Paikin was polite but he asked pointed questions and gave Dougie enough rope to hang himself with.
One thing I didn't like was when he pressed Dougie for some examples of what the Star had gotten wrong about Rob Ford. Dougie had to reach all the way back to the accusation about Rob roughing up one of his football players. Paikin should have come back with, "Okay, but that was many years ago, when your brother was still a councillor. What have they got wrong about Rob Ford in the three and a half years he's been mayor?"
Anyway, the clip is up on youtube:
[video=youtube;e5FaLAByje0]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e5FaLAByje0[/video]