When Toronto's sidewalks turn into ice rinks, it doesn't take long for city council to get a brain freeze
By JOE WARMINGTON
Toronto Sun
Tue, February 12, 2008
It's like a skating rink out there on Toronto sidewalks.
No, really, I am not kidding.
You can skate on many of them. I did yesterday.
To be honest, I felt much safer doing that than walking. It was pure ice and for that you need skates. Watch my video on torontosun.com and you will see for yourself. I even did a little stick-handling with a puck -- but not as much stick-handling as some on city council seem to be doing on this issue.
For me it's a classic case of rink rage.
Once again some of our out-of-touch city councillors huffing and puffing about trying to fine people for not shovelling their sidewalks were nowhere to be found to put a little salt or sand down to protect our children or seniors from being severely hurt.
The truth is, no matter the politics, in many areas the sidewalks are treacherous. Time bombs, actually. I personally saw six people slip and fall on sidewalks yesterday. And I almost fell once myself.
"It happened to me too," said Justin Van Dette, an assistant to Councillor John Parker at city hall. "I was just walking along St. Clair when I slipped. Luckily I landed on my brief case."
PARKING TICKET SYSTEM
Of course, if many down at city hall had it their way they'd not only blame you, but also try to fine you too. Seriously!
"My hope is that we can find a legal way to do this on a more proactive basis," Councillor Joe Mihevc said in a Saturday Toronto Sun story by Zen Ruryk, adding he would like to see "some system similar to parking tickets" implemented.
The great tax collector, Mihevc was said to be "at a conference in Ottawa" yesterday and did not return my call. I don't think Ottawa is far enough away for that to be excusable, but maybe he can get some tips at the Rideau Canal on how to better maintain a skating rink because there are lots around our city right now.
Thanks to a snowfall, a thaw and then a freeze, you have some very dangerous areas out there.
I noticed it down in Riverdale when I was at the Maple Leafs outdoor practice at Withrow Park. Getting to the rink was a real chore and I was teasing the top-notch City of Toronto parks and recreation rink and Zamboni guys -- Steve Boyko, Ron Perkins, David Green, Clyde Preston and Dave Barr -- since the Leafs were so happy with their outdoor skate they should take that machine out and flood the sidewalks too.
As people were leaving that great event, I could tell Councillor Paula Fletcher was not amused at how the conditions were in her ward. We don't agree on much but you can't say she doesn't work hard for her constituents.
"I agree with you," she said, adding she also agrees the idea of fining people for poor sidewalk maintenance is just not logical.
And yet this is the mindset of so many at city hall. They figure the sidewalks are the solely the homeowners' responsibility. But it's actually not true. You dig into this and you'll find that the city actually does plow many city sidewalks.
"We spend $30-million a year on it," said Councillor Rob Ford. "So I don't understand what this is all about. The city is supposed to do it."
Well, in some neighbourhoods at least. Not all is equal, it turns out. It's different from neighbourhood to neighbourhood. "Confusing," is the word Parker used to describe it. "I think we need to clarify this for people."
So as I understand it, only some sections of the city have to take care of their own sidewalks while others have it plowed. But the poor shmucks in the areas who don't have the special sidewalk-cleaning machine are on the hook for maintaining the walkways - but still paying the same taxes as those in the neighbourhoods that do.
Crazy. In fact this winter more than 600 homes have been warned by city staffers and more than 100 have been fined $125. "Any senior will tell you that during a snowfall ... if the sidewalks aren't clear, they feel unsafe walking the street," Mihevc said in Saturday's paper. "It's a matter of public courtesy, community decency for all of us to shovel the snow."
If you are in a union it's a little more lucrative for you, though. It boggles the mind with the taxes people pay, why aren't the sidewalks a city responsibility? But it has to be asked: What happens when there is a section of the street where there are no homes?
Who is going to clear those areas? Well, if yesterday is any indicator, how about nobody?
And the city has no answer for this. It's something that has slipped between the cracks. And that means people are slipping on the ice.
SALT, SAND
Councillor Glenn DeBaermaker, chair of Toronto Public Works, said one of the problems are some "lazy" people are "sitting in their homes eating popcorn" while others are out shovelling.
And while that may be true, it still doesn't change the fact that the sidewalks are icy and very dangerous. Passing the buck or blame would hardly cut it in the court of law where the liability of those sidewalks rests with the city.
I say rather than handing out tickets, city workers should bring some salt and sand to the darned sidewalks and don't worry about Mihevc's desire to ding more people.
DeBaermaker, who received dozens of complaints yesterday, agrees the current approach needs to be modified and Rob Ford put it all in perspective with this: "Just take the money needed out of Kyle Rae's upcoming trip to a conference in Mexico and use it to buy some bags of salt."
Until that's done, you can play hockey or speed-skate on Toronto's sidewalks. Hope there's not a fine for that!
•
You can call Joe Warmington at (416) 947-2392 or e-mail at joe.warmington@sunmedia.ca