christiesplits
Senior Member
I had such low expectations for the reclad. It’s not as terrible as I was expecting.
It certainly makes Old City Hall pop.
It certainly makes Old City Hall pop.
- Thread starter androiduk
- Start date
DSC
Superstar
If this were a NEW building built on a vacant lot it would be 'unmemorable' but it is a new skin put onto an older building and needs to be judged on whether it was done 'sensitively' - I would say that it wasn't.
Red Mars
Senior Member
Mar 18, 2020
Amare
Senior Member
This one picture singlehandedly illustrates everything that's wrong with this re-clad and why it's truly horrific from head to toe.
Yegger
Active Member
Am i seeing things or are there truly two toned aluminum panels (white and darker grey?). If so, this reclad is really reaching unprecedented levels of repulsiveness.
DSC
Superstar
The pink highlight panels are on back-order.
DarkSideDenizen
Senior Member
Still like the original better..
Too much grey, here's a dash of colour:
Too much grey, here's a dash of colour:
steveve
Senior Member
Today:
khris
Senior Member
Oh man this is just so ugly. And in such a prominent location. Really unfortunate.
Red Mars
Senior Member
Tue Apr 21, 2020
.dwg
Active Member
Design, from start to end of CD's, takes years. How did this possibly pass through so many hands and have so many eyes on it in that time and STILL turn out so badly?
If I had shown a senior designer or studio professor this - even as a misguided first concept sketch - it would be tossed aside in favour of better options. It's like an associate took a liking to the 5th concept that a student intern did - you know, the one that they did just for the sake of having a 5th option to show even though the 5th one is just terrible and they know their boss won't ask for it to be explored further.
If I had shown a senior designer or studio professor this - even as a misguided first concept sketch - it would be tossed aside in favour of better options. It's like an associate took a liking to the 5th concept that a student intern did - you know, the one that they did just for the sake of having a 5th option to show even though the 5th one is just terrible and they know their boss won't ask for it to be explored further.
UtakataNoAnnex
Senior Member
Lack of imagination. Or no respect for the building's past. Pick your poison.
...the more troubling question though: How did they make something so gray more depressingly gray? /sigh
...the more troubling question though: How did they make something so gray more depressingly gray? /sigh
DSC
Superstar
and how come they took so long about doing it? The permit was applied for early in 2014 and the first photo on this thread showing construction was November 2015.
UtakataNoAnnex
Senior Member
ProjectEnd
Superstar
Most, if not everyone, at Cad Fairview thinks this looks a-ok. Not a joke.