PMT
Senior Member
Pre-construction community presentation for Rosedale station:
|
|
|
- Thread starter PMT
- Start date
Northern Light
Superstar
DSCToronto
Superstar
Yes, that's an amazingly long project for a station that has no other buildings nearby to make things complicated. The TTC needs to look at the schedule! (Oh, I forgot. It's the TTC : schedules are simply an annoying distraction!)
H4F33Z
Active Member
and it'll still be delayed!
W. K. Lis
Superstar
Richard White
Senior Member
I trust you have never visited London, UK? The Hammersmith and City line is almost entirely outdoors while a large chunk of other stations on the more prominent lines are as well. They are not demanding enclosure of all their stations.
Enclosing stations is a frill that is not really done unless there is no other option.
Northern Light
Superstar
With great respect; London doesn't get much snow; and is nowhere near as cold in the winter months.
Its really not a reasonable comparison, any more than comparing Toronto to Vancouver or Miami.
You could reasonably compare Montreal or Chicago.
But if you've ever been on Chicago's El...........well, the experience, I would argue leaves something to be desired, as do many of the stations.
Last edited:
W. K. Lis
Superstar
The same reason elevators were not installed on the original Yonge subway. The designers were not handicapped at the time of design. Wonder if the current designers of any of the public transit projects even use public transit today.
felix123
Active Member
What a weird flex. "You clearly haven't been to London, where many a tube station is merry and uncovered, you poor, uncultured country bumpkin."
There's a stronger argument for fully covering a subway station in Toronto than there would be in London: weather.
ARG1
Senior Member
Since Metrolinx is considering installed PSDs, it would be more than easy to have the platforms be climate controlled environments.
W. K. Lis
Superstar
There's this new invention called "screens". So it won't be "sealed".
EastYorkTTCFan
Senior Member
People seem to have this idea that when they put in platform edge doors they will be full length and then the TTC is going to spend money retrofitting every subway station to have heating and Air conditioning systems in them.
Northern Light
Superstar
While Platform-Edge-Doors are a pre-requisite for A/C or Central Heat; that it most certainly not planned or budgeted for in the preliminary project plans.
If the PEDs were full-height and substantially sealed off the air flow from the tunnels, the stations would overwhelmingly require new ventilation systems.
That would be more expensive than the PEDs themselves.
It would be possible to do directional heaters, such as those being into bus shelters onto portion of select platforms; but to be of any utility, you would likely require a semi-enclosed shelter on the platform itself.
This isn't a particularly likely outcome.
The biggest benefit of this type that may result from PEDs is that it might cause new stations to have HVAC in the design.
Retrofitting older stations is likely a very, very long way away.
EastYorkTTCFan
Senior Member
I don't really see that happening either because of the added expense of it. Is there any system in the world that is either operating or being built that has full HVAC in its stations or even some of them?
Northern Light
Superstar
Riyadh, in Saudi Arabia (under construction)
Tokyo Metro has air conditioning at many underground stations (not sure about all)
Tokyo Metro subway stations to heat up from Friday
This summer, the hottest spots in Tokyo may be stations on the underground, speculates Weekly Playboy (July 11). On June 15, Tokyo Metro announced that as one of its power-saving measures, on weekdays from noon to 3 p.m., air conditioning would be turned off at its stations, beginning from July…
japantoday.com
Underground stations in New Delhi also have a/c
Metro to have improved air-conditioning to beat summer heat
With the city in the grip of a heat wave, the Delhi Metro is equipping its new trains with improved air-conditioning system that can maintain 25 degree Celsius temperature inside the cars even when th
Guangzhou Metro is putting a/c in their new stations (not sure if its in older ones)
Tehran's system has a/c in all the stations I believe.