My spidey sense is tingling...
Spider, I'm not sure why you don't want this facility, other than cost, but all of your arguments are... suspect.
First of all, for those of us who have kids playing hockey in Riverdale, our choices are Leaside (packed) and East York (ditto). Moss Park has a sort-of house league program, but not a real house league or rep teams.
Leaside is so packed that it's causing issues by trying to find better ice times for its girls. Ted Reeves has put a bubble on the back lot to twin its arena. Our beloved Moss Park may be the crappiest arena on the planet. Where's the frickin' four pad?
So, a new arena five minutes drive from my house would be excellent, thanks. And, for any of those condo dwellers in CityPlace, Harbourfront, along Bay, etc. etc. who'd rather drive to Cherry than Rinx/York U/Lakeshore/Agincourt/Pickering (one buddy of mine), a new arena'd be great, thanks.
Hey, I'm the first to admit that I'd be happy with the original, suburban design. I'm looking for hockey in the 'nabe, not design. But, I understand why others would prefer dropping an extra 20% to design a better building, to be offset by increased density charges to developers and a bigger, better park.
Last, but not least, when was the GTHL actually relevant in any hockey discussion in Toronto? Early '60s?
Cheers.