See the thing is other than the beer movement (Toronto has it corned there.) These other cities have all those things. kkgg is harsh, but i feel it is out of love and not scorn. There are things we could do much better. Personally, I think Toronto sits back way too much, we need to be a go getter. I think business taxes are too high, but that's just me.
Which other cities? New York? London? Absolutely.
But Paris, for example, has absolutely horrible non-french food in general. Terrible.
If you are judging Paris, you must immerse yourself in French food before you can judge its culinary scene (which is fantastic).
In Toronto, likewise, you need to immerse yourself in the local culture to appreciate the great food on offer. I sincerely doubt kkgg7 and others have done this.
Again, BarVolo is arguably better than any NY equivalent, but even if you want to claim it isn't superior to Blind Tiger, you'd have to admit they are on par. Someone that doesn't know what I'm talking about isn't experiencing the best of Toronto.
The 'arepas' at Arepa Café are probably the best ones you can find outside of Venezuela (I lived in Caracas, I know what I'm talking about). The sandwiches at Café Bernaté, the mind-blowingly cheap and delicious cheese empanadas at Jumbo Empanada, the best fresh alfajores I've had outside of S. America at El Almacén (where you can have awesome Mate). The 3 funghi pizza at Queen Margherita Pizza is almost the best one I've ever had (best one is made by this lovely old couple from Lazio I know, though it's a roman-type pizza which is different). Chocosol make incredible chocolate and sell toasted cocoa beans that can be eaten by themselves and are by all means heavenly.
All of the above are CHEAP easily available treats made by people who love making them (I've talked to the owners/family of all these places as I'm a regular).
A city's greatness is a subjective thing. If you have the sensitivity and open mind to appreciate the places I've listed above, chances are you love Toronto dearly, and hold it up there with the best.
I can tell you that, for example, that having lived in Miami there's no comparison in terms of the quality of retail. Miami's is more refined and corporate, but it ultimately lacks substance and passion.