JWBF
Senior Member
Soknacki is shooting himself in the foot by wanting to go back to the LRT plan. If Toronto City Council were to actually go back to the LRT plan, then bringing better transit to Scarborough gets pushed back yet again.
LRVs are a better alternative than the crap we have right now. And quite a few of us remember when the SRT was shortened to use the mrk1 cars, not unlike what using HRVs (underground or not) would do to the people of Scarborough for a second time. Transit is needed in the densest parts of Scarborough which is in the Malvern and Eglinton (Kennedey to Kingston), not even the new plan has a stop at Brimmley or Danforth.
Besides, the current Liberal government is pushing for a subway instead. Heck, even if Tim Hudak's Tories get elected this spring (We all know an election is coming), a subway is still coming to Scarborough. In the end, it doesn't matter if he wants the LRT plan because it's completely dead in the water. A subway extension is coming. I think Soknacki should accept the Bloor-Danforth extension but push for more LRT like on Sheppard in Scarborough. That's a win win for him.
At least, if we are to get no new transit then the plan along the present SRT corridor will not give Toronto a new debt, especially one Robbie and others would be paid for by anyone but Toronto.
There still needs to be an environmental assessment (for one) on both proposed routes, and if neither can provide the proper numbers then a subway extension still might not happen. As far as I know, the SRT alignment is still being used in transit maps for future development, for HRVs or LRVs.
Well, I disagree with you that the Scarborough subway is a terrible financial mistake. I think it's the right choice for the route that is being pushed for (McCowan), but Soknacki could also campaign on what Karen Stintz had in her OneCity plan - a Scarborough-Malvern LRT from Kennedy station up to the future Morningside Station.
Surely you mean Danforth-McCowan? Scarborough-Malvern was part of the original Transit City, and a part of it that should have not been cancelled since it serve some of the densest areas of Scarborough.
Going with the LRT plan would give the transit levy over to extending it properly into the Malvern area, or the aforementioned Malvern-Scarborough LRT.
It’s an extension of the Bloor-Danforth subway (Kennedy to Sheppard), not a “Scarborough Subway”. We have had three subway stops in Scarborough since November 1980 (a little more than 32 years), it’s the other half that needs more than just more buses.