Kilroy
Active Member
Actually, nothing posted so far would prevent Karla from being regarded as Jewish by matrilineal tradition. All of her female forebears and other female relatives could have married non-Jews and/or converted to religions other than Judaeism; as long as she is lineally descended from a Jewish female then she is Jewish by matrilineal tradition (which does not recognize conversation as being effective).
Asking about her wedding only relates to finding at least some indication about whether she has ever given serious attention to being Jewish prior to Doug coming home fuming about the debate last night.
So.. could be technically considered Jewish if any direct female ancestor in the last 1000 years considered herself Jewish.
Therefore, we can't absolutely prove he's lying...
But it doesn't really matter, because, we know he's lying based on the evidence presented in the forum.
And that doesn't really matter, because FN will give him 25% no matter what.
And that doesn't matter because it doesn't move anyone from Tory to Chow, or vice versa.
Therefore, no change.
Last edited: