If Bob Kinnear met up with a mob of angry and irrational TTC patrons at 12:01a.m., I'd love to see the ambulance driver stop for 10 minutes to grab a slice on the way to the hospital.
After all, the ambulance driver's only human!
This is a very interesting article. Apparently it's all about a power struggle between Kinnear and even-more-radical members of the executive. Apparently some of them are even angry about operating extra hours during Nuit Blanche and New Year's Eve. They will show absolutely no flexibility of any kind on anything, it seems to suggest. These radical members used the long gap between the signing and the vote on the contract to spread doomsday stories about maintenance workers throughout the system.
Province to end TTC walkout
All parties expected to support back-to-work legislation in rare emergency session today
Apr 27, 2008 04:30 AM
Tess Kalinowski
Robert Benzie
Staff Reporters
The weekend-long shocker of a TTC strike should be over in time for tomorrow morning's commute.
Premier Dalton McGuinty will table back-to-work legislation this afternoon in a rare emergency Sunday session of the Legislature, in which all three parties are expected to vote in favour of forcing 9,000 striking members of the Amalgamated Transit Union back on the job.
Failure to abide by the law would result in hefty fines for the union.
Talks yesterday between Local 113 of the union and management were called off around dinnertime after meetings between a provincial mediator, the union and TTC management failed to reach a new deal.
The union and TTC management sides spent only about 15 minutes in the same room, said TTC chief general manager Gary Webster.
The union "shocked" TTC management with a long list of demands, some of which were very different from what was agreed to last week, said Webster who is expected to notify workers to return to the job as soon as the back-to-work law passes today. It will take only about three or four hours to set the TTC in motion again, he said.
Union president Bob Kinnear refused to speak with reporters who staked out the Richmond Hill hotel where talks were taking place, fuelling speculation that the union is experiencing a leadership crisis.
Last Sunday's tentative contract settlement was rejected by 65 per cent of the union members on Friday, who walked off the job at midnight leaving furious riders stranded throughout the city and about 1.6 million people who normally ride the TTC on a weekend looking for other means of transportation.
An angry Mayor David Miller made it clear yesterday he never expected the return to bargaining would be successful.
"The union executive clearly can't deliver its membership so even if we negotiated a settlement there's no guarantee that they can deliver their membership," he said.
If legislated back to work, the union will likely receive an arbitrated settlement. It's unclear if it will give the workers the same provisions that were negotiated earlier, including a 3 per cent increase in each year of a three-year contract, a 20-cent premium for skilled trades, improvements in dental, insurance and injury benefits and a GTA clause that guarantees TTC drivers are the highest paid in the region.
McGuinty, who has been in constant contact with Miller since the snap walkout, promised to move the legislation quickly.
New Democratic Party Leader Howard Hampton and Progressive Conservative Leader John Tory indicated they would support the back-to-work legislation.
Hampton, who warned earlier in the day that his party wasn't going "to buy a pig in a poke" before closely studying the legislation, said New Democrats would support the bill.
The NDP's stance was key because they had the power to deny the all-party consent necessary to pass the legislation in one day. That would have prolonged the job action.
TTC chair Adam Giambrone said that under the circumstances, the TTC sustained little damage to its property aside from some broken windows and doors, and graffiti.
He stressed that even though the union failed to live up to a commitment to give 48 hours' notice of a strike, the walkout was legal.
Giambrone urged the public to remember the strike was a union matter and pleaded for the public not to punish TTC staff for the inconvenience. "What we've said all along is this was never about drivers. It's not fair for people to take their anger out on individuals."
Insiders say the strike was triggered by divisions inside the union and possibly some missteps by Kinnear and the executive. "It's a power struggle. There are a number of people who would like to take over (from Kinnear)," one source said.
It's possible the deal sunk simply because too much time elapsed between last Sunday's settlement and Friday's ratification vote.
The outcome might have been different had union members voted Tuesday.
But the lag gave those undermining the settlement a chance to spread misinformation about the impact of the contract on the maintenance workers and mechanics, who comprise about 4,000 of the 9,000 members.
Some believe the operators felt compelled to support fellow union members and vote down the deal.
Sources said reports were overstated of maintenance workers and mechanics being upset about the GTA clause guaranteeing drivers the highest wage among regional transit workers. One union insider said the misinformation about the settlement "snowballed."
"This was the old guard versus the new guard," said a source, of the apparent split in the executive. Two signatures – executive vice-president and assistant business agent, maintenance – were still missing from a signed copy of the contract obtained by the Star yesterday.
But another source said Kinnear probably has enough executive support to survive the crisis.
"Bob will not resign," said the source. "He has enough support to be able to block that."
Despite his confrontational, public reputation, Kinnear is a reasonable leader, say TTC insiders. If he is forced out, some of the flexibility that makes the system work for special events such as Nuit Blanche or extended hours at New Year's Eve could be more difficult.
The union's gambit should bolster McGuinty's threat to declare the TTC an essential service prohibited from striking. He has signalled his displeasure with the recurring threats of transit strikes in Toronto.
While the Legislative Assembly has sat on Sundays before – the last time being in 1997 during a filibuster surrounding the amalgamation of Toronto by then Tory premier Mike Harris – today is believed to be the first time the House has been recalled for a Sunday.
Getting the Legislature back involved tricky protocol issues. Government House Leader Michael Bryant's office prepared an order in council to facilitate the session.
After McGuinty and Education Minister Kathleen Wynne, the chair of cabinet, signed the one-page order, an official had to drive it to the Scarborough home of Lieutenant Governor David Onley for his signature.
Ironically, traffic gridlock slightly delayed the reconvening of the Legislature. By law, there must be 24 hours' notice to recall the House and gridlock from Queen's Park to Scarborough meant the earliest it could meet was 1:30 p.m. today.
With files from David Bruser